Tall Timbers Research Station, Route 1, Box 160, Tallahassee, Florida 32312 USA;
'ZNational Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560 USA; and
:Department of Biological Sciences, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida 32816 USA
Little is known of the extent of movement and
winter ranges of Clapper Rails (Rallus longirostris) in
the United States despite years of study by orni-
thologists and game biologists (Stewart 1951, 1954;
Mangold 1977). For example, only recently was it
learned that the endangered southwestern popula-
tion, R. l. yumanensis, leaves its breeding grounds in
the Colorado River Valley to winter in Mexico (Tom-
linson and Todd 1973, Banks and Tomlinson 1974).
Populations in the southeastern states are thought to
be largely nonmigratory and strictly confined to
coastal areas (Adams and Quay 1958). The northern
subsepcies, R. l. crepitans, is known to range south
in winter along the Atlantic Coast as far as the vi-
TABLE 1. Recent specimens of migrant or out-of-range Clapper Rails from Florida.
Museum Locality in Florida Date Age/sex Collector
Rallus longirostris crepitans
USNM 525849 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Nov 1966 Adult 9 Olson, W. M. Hobbs
USNM 525880 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Nov 1966 Adult 9 Olson, W.M. Hobbs
USNM 525881 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Nov 1966 Adult 9 Olson, W.M. Hobbs
USNM 525850 Wakulla Co., Shell Pt. 23 Sep 1961 Immature c Olson et al.
UCF 206 Orange Co., WDBO tower 11 Sep 1969 Adult 9 Taylor
Rallus longirostris waynei
USNM 525848 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Nov 1966 Adult c Olson, W. M. Hobbs
TTRS 2811 Leon Co., Tallahassee 6 Oct 1965 Immature 9 H.M. Stevenson
TTRS 3664 Leon Co., WCTV tower 9 Apr 1980 Adult 9 Crawford
UCF 900 Brevard Co., Merritt Is., VAB 30 Sep 1971 Adult 9 L. Ellis, R. Bush
UCF 901 Brevard Co., Merritt Is., VAB 20 Oct 1971 Adult 9 L. Ellis, R. Bush
UCF 916 Pinelias Co. (northern) Oct 1969 Adult 9 V. Morrison
Rallus longirostris scottii
UCF 875 Brevard Co., Merritt Is., VAB 28 Sep 1971 Adult 9 L. Ellis, R. Bush
UCF 897 Brevard Co., Merritt Is., VAB 28 Sep 1971 Adult 9 L. Ellis, R. Bush
Rallus longirostris scottii > waynei
UCF 899 Brevard Co., Merritt Is., VAB 25 May 1971 Adult 9 L. Ellis, R. Bush
Rallus longirostris saturatus
USNM 525878 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Nov 1966 Adult 9 Olson, W. M. Hobbs
USNM 525877 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 23 Nov 1966 Adult c Olson, W. M. Hobbs
USNM 525875 Franklin Co., Turkey Pt. 4 Mar 1967 Adult 9 Olson
TTRS 2810 Leon Co., Tallahassee 27 Jul 1937 Adtlt 9 M.K. Gibson
' USNM - National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution; UCF - University of Central Florida; TTRS = Tall Timbers Research
Station.
0 R I, saturatus ß R,I waynei
I R.i crephans
Historic Ranges
R I waynei
Zone of intergradation
Fig. 1. Distribution of Clapper Rails (Rallus longirostris) in Florida with locations of significant new
specimen records.
cinity of Jacksonville, Florida (A.O.U. 1957), but the
remaining subspecies (waynei, scottii, insularurn, and
saturatus) are believed to be sedentary, with seasonal
movements and inland occurrences being limited to
aberrant stragglers rather than migrants (Fig. 1,
Howell 1932, Oberholser 1937, A.O.U. 1957, Man-
gold 1977, Kale 1978). Recent banding studies on the
Georgia coast, however, indicate the possibility of
regular long-distance movements (Hon et al. 1977).
One Clapper Rail banded there in September 1974
was recovered in Maryland in May 1975. Another,
banded in August 1975, was recovered at Merritt Is-
land, Florida in November 1975. Herein, we report
more evidence of overland or long-distance move-
ments by Clapper Rails based on subspecifically
identified specimens obtained during our indepen-
dent studies (Table 1, Fig. 1).
The data presented here indicate that the winter
ranges of various subspecies of Clapper Rails in Flor-
ida have been, and still are, very imperfectly under-
stood. The distinctive, pale northern race R. 1. crepi-
tans, heretofore thought to occur only rarely in Florida
on the northeast coast, is now known from much
farther south and inland in Orange County (Taylor
and Anderson 1973), but more significantly on the
northern coast of the Gulf of Mexico in Franklin and
Wakulla counties. The subspecies of the middle At-
lantic Coast, R. 1. waynei, stated to occur on the At-
lantic Coast in winter south only to Merritt Island,
has several times struck the Vehicle Assembly Build-
ing (VAB) at Merritt Island during fall migration, im-
plying movement farther to the south. Indeed, How-
ell (1932) reported a specimen of waynei taken in April
1920 at Jupiter, 160 km south of Merritt Island. This
subspecies has also been taken on the Gulf Coast in
Franklin and Pinelias counties and 40 km inland from
the Gulf in Leon County. Olson maintains some res-
ervations about the distinctiveness of the subspecies
R. 1. saturatus of the western Gulf Coast, mainly be-
cause the vast majority of available specimens from
the range of that form are in quite worn plumage.
Nevertheless, specimens matching those assigned to
saturatus have been taken as far east as Franklin
County and inland in Leon County (Stevenson 1950,
1962; and specimens examined in this study), where-
as this subsepcies had been thought to occur nor-
mally no farther east than Pensacola, Florida (Ober-
holser 1937). The peninsular race R. 1. scottii,
previously thought not to extend farther north on the
Atlantic Coast than the vicinity of Jupiter, has now
been taken as far north as Merritt Island, where it
has been killed during nocturnal flights at the VAB.
The data presented here provide considerable evi-
dence for mixing of populations of Clapper Rails in
Florida in winter. Noteworthy in this context is that
on 4 November 1966 Olson and W. M. Hobbs col-
lected specimens of four different subspecies (crep-
itans, waynei, scottii, and saturatus) in a single small
area of salt marsh at Turkey Point, Franklin County.
The presence of the northeastern subspecies crepi-
tans at two localities on the northern Gulf Coast of
Florida is an almost certain indication of overland
flight, as it is extremely unlikely that these birds
would have flown the 1,200 km around the tip of
peninsular Florida. The inland occurrences are like-
wise probably indications of overland movements.
In addition to those previously mentioned, there is
a specimen of R. I. waynei, now at the University of
Georgia, that was killed at Atlanta, Georgia on 1 Sep-
tember 1971 (French 1972).
We agree with Hon et al. (1977) that the evidence
as yet is too meager to decide whether these move-
ments represent postbreeding dispersal, migration,
or merely aberrant wanderers, although we regard
the last as the least likely. For example, two of the
subspecies of Clapper Rails in the western U.S. are
known to disperse, migrate, or both (Wilbur and
Tomlinson 1976). There is a highly skewed sex and
age ratio among the specimens listed in Table 1. Of
18 specimens taken out-of-range or in migration, 15
are females and 16 are adults. Both of these ratios are
significantly at variance from equality by simple Chi-
squared tests (P 0.0005). The specimen of R. I.
waynei from Jupiter, now at the Museum of Com-
parative Zoology, is also a female (R. A. Paynter, Jr.
in litt.); the Atlanta specimen of waynei is a male
(Lloyd Logan pers. comm.). In species known to be
"partial migrants" females are usually the more mi-
gratory sex (Lack 1944, Baker 1978: 636).
Additional collecting during the late fall and win-
ter is needed before the true extent and nature of
movements among the eastern races of the Clapper
Rail can be properly assessed. Meanwhile, it seems
likely that inland occurrences are the result of normal
patterns of dispersal or migration rather than of dis-
oriented stragglers.
Identifications of specimens in Table 1 were con-
firmed by Olson with assistance from M. Ralph
Browning. We are also grateful to R. C. Laybourne,
R. C. Banks, and H. W. Kale II for their previous
identifications of certain of these specimens. Tip Hon
and H. M. Stevenson generously shared their re-
search material. Lucy Laffitte prepared the figure.
LITERATURE CITED
ADAMS, D. A., & T. L. QUAY. 1958. Ecology of the
Clapper Rail in southeastern North Carolina. J.
Wildl. Mgrnt. 22: 149-156.
AMERICAN ORNITHOLOGISTS' UNION. 1957. Check-
list of North American birds, fifth ed. Baltimore,
Maryland, Amer. Ornithol. Union.
BAKER, R.R. 1978. The evolutionary ecology of an-
imal migration. New York, Holmes & Meier Pub.,
Inc.
BANKS, R. C., & R. E. TOMLINSON. 1974. Taxonomic
status of certain Clapper Rails of southwestern
United States and northwestern Mexico. Wilson
Bull. 86: 325-335.
FRENCH, T. 1972. Clapper Rail in downtown Atlan-
ta. Oriole 37: 5-6.
HON, T., R. R. ODUM, & D. P. BELCHER. 1977. Re-
sults of Georgia's Clapper Rail banding pro-
gram. Proc. Ann. Conf. S.E. Assoc. Fish Wildl.
Agencies 31: 72-76.
HOWELL, A. H. 1932. Florida bird life. New York,
Coward-McCann, Inc.
KALE, H. W., II. 1978. Florida Clapper Rail Railus
longirostris scottii Sennett. Pp. 112-113 in Rare
and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 2: Birds
(H. W. Kale II, Ed.). Gainesville, Florida, Univ.
Presses of Florida.
LACK, D. 1944. The problem of partial migration.
Brit. Birds 37: 122-130, 143-150.
MANGOLD, R. E. 1977. Clapper Rail (Railus longi-
rostris). Pp. 84-92 in Management of migratory
shore and upland game birds in North America
(G. C. Sanderson, Ed.). Washington, D.C., In-
ternatl. Assoc. Fish Wildl. Agencies.
OBERHOLSER, H. C. 1937. A revision of the Clapper
Rails (Railus longirostris Boddaert). Proc. U.S.
Natl. Mus. 84 (3018): 313-354.
STEVENSON, H. M. 1950. Distribution of certain
birds in the southeastern United States. Amer.
Midl. Natur. 43: 605-626.
1962. Clapper Rail in the interior of Flori-
da--a correction. Amer. Midl. Natur. 67: 505.
STEWART, R. E. 1951. Clapper Rail populations of
the middle Atlantic states. Trans. 16th North
Amer. Wildl. Conf.: 421-430.
1954. Migratory movements of the North-
em Clapper Rail. Bird-Banding 25: 1-5.
TAYLOR, W. K., & B. H. ANDERSON. 1973. Noctur-
nal migrants killed at a central Florida TV tower:
autumns 1969-1971. Wilson Bull. 85: 42-51.
TOMLINSON, R. E., & R. L. TODD. 1973. Distribu-
tion of two western Clapper Rail races as deter-
mined by responses to taped calls. Condor 75:
177-183.
WILBUR, S. R., & R. E. TOMLINSON. 1976. The lit-
erature of the western Clapper Rails. U.S. Fish
Wildl. Serv. Spec. Sci. Rept.--Wildl. No. 194.
Received 23 February 1982, accepted 8 July 1982.