EDITED BY CARL D. MARTI
The following critiques express the opinions of the individual evaluators regarding the strengths,
weaknesses, and value of the books they reviem As such, the appraisals are subjective assessments
and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the editors or any official policy of the American
Ornithologists' Union.
Ornithologen-Briefe des 20 Jahrhunderts.--Jiir-
gen Haffer (with contributions by Ernst Mayr).
1997. Okologie der V6gel, vol. 19. 980 pp., 76 text
figures. ISSN 0173-0711. 120 DM (available from
Jochen H61zinger, Auf der Schanz 23/2, D-71640
Ludwigsburg, Germany).--This massive tome of
nearly 1,000 pages is a huge and sweeping saga of
ornithology spanning more than 100 years and two
world wars. Two main historical themes are
stressed (1) the development of systematics and the
species concept within ornithology, and (2) the rise
of fresh approaches in ornithology--the new avian
biology. Haffer's analysis is based on letters and
other documents in the large Stresemann archives
in Berlin, as well as other collections of ornitholog-
ical documents, and on his earlier analyses of the
history of systematics and the species concept in or-
nithology. Almost all of the discussions are in En-
glish, but the letters are reproduced in the language
in which they were written (mostly German). Or-
nithologen-Briefe is not only an excellent history of
an important aspect of ornithology during the past
100 years, it is a major source for additional re-
search because the letters contain extensive mate-
rial not used by Haffer for his analyses.
Ornithologen-Briefe is so vast that it is difficult to
know where to start, but as usual, it is best to start
at the beginning, which is the history of avian sys-
tematics and the species concept. This section may be
surprising to some because it commences with two
systematists who are little known to ornithologists
and completely unknown to historians of science,
namely Henry Seebohm of the United Kingdom and
Count Hans Berlepsch of Germany.
Seebohm, a wealthy amateur ornithologist who as-
sembled and studied a large collection of birds, was
influenced in the 1870s by Darwin and by the trinom-
inal nomenclature of the North American school of
Baird, Coues, and others. He described geographic
variation in avian species as subspecies in strong op-
position to the binomial approach adopted by almost
all British ornithologists at that time. His 1887 mono-
graph of the Charadriidae was an early analysis of
the evolutionary history of an avian family based on
the idea of geographic speciation. Seebohm was
clearly one of the major founders of the new ap-
proach to avian systematics in Europe, which Haffer
designated as the Seebohm-Hartert School.
Berlepsch amassed the most important private col-
lection of birds in Germany and was an active sys-
tematic ornithologist, but he was far more important
as a mentor of Ernst Hartert, Karl Jordan, Charles
Hellmayr, and Otto Kleinschmidt. Berlepsch was in-
strumental in obtaining positions for Hartert and
Jordan at the Tring Museum, thereby establishing the
important "Tring triumvirate" of Lord Rothschild,
Hartert, and Jordan. Furthermore, he assisted Hell-
mayr in obtaining his position at the Zoologische
Staatssammlung in Munich. Interestingly, in his ear-
ly work Berlepsch adopted the subspecies concept
and trinominal nomenclature, but he abandoned this
approach in about 1895 under the influence of Anton
Reichenow and became a strong opponent of the sys-
tematic ideas of the several workers he assisted early
in their careers.
Ernst Hartert, a self-trained naturalist and system-
atist, was appointed in 1892 by Lord Rothschild as
director of his private museum in Tring. He oversaw
the great increase in the bird collection that reached
about 280,000 specimens (the largest and most im-
portant private collection ever assembled) by the
time he retired in 1930. Hartert was largely respon-
sible for decisions as to where Rothschild's collectors
were sent. He studied most of these collections, fi-
nally describing more than 1,000 species and sub-
species of birds. Yet, Hartert is best known for his
three-volume Die Vigel der paliiarktischen Fauna. Har-
tert worked within a Darwinian perspective and was
largely responsible for convincing avian systematists
to use the subspecies concept and trinominal no-
menclature. Clearly, Hartert was the second founder
of the "Seebohm-Hartert School" and was a central
figure in the development of modern avian system-
atics.
Haffer details the interwoven lineage of a group
of ornithologists belonging to the Seebohm-Hartert
School. Carl E. Hellmayr was the mentor of Erwin
Stresemann in his early training around 1910 before
Hellmayr left for Chicago in 1922. Stresemann held
the leading position in ornithology for much of the
first half of the 20th century as curator of birds in
Berlin (replacing Anton Reichenow), as the author
of the Aves volume in the Handbuch der Zoologie ed-
ited by W. Ktikenthal and T. Krumbach, as long-
time editor of the Journal fiir Ornithologie (1922 to
1961), and as Secretary-General/President of the
Deutschen Ornithologen-Gesellschaft. He was also
the teacher and/or mentor of Bernhard Rensch and
Ernst Mayr, two of the younger members of this
school, during their tenure at the Zoological Mu-
seum Berlin. Rensch left Berlin for the Universitit
Mtinster in 1937, and Mayr left Berlin for the Amer-
ican Museum of Natural History in January 1931.
Stresemann first corresponded with Hartert in 1910
and soon became a close personal friend and great
admirer of Hartert (the most interesting fact in this
book is that Stresemann, by his own wish, is buried
in the same grave with Hartert in the Berlin-Dah-
lem Waldfriedhof, with both names inscribed on
the tombstone). A falcon drawn by O. Kleinschmidt
is etched on this tombstone. All of these workers re-
mained close friends and colleagues throughout
their lives. This circle of friends also included Lord
Rothschild and Leonard C. Sanford, the latter a
long-time trustee of the American Museum of Nat-
ural History and one who was largely responsible
for the development of the museum's Department
of Ornithology to its preeminent position. Otto
Kleinschmidt was the last member of the earlier
non-evolutionary, essentialistic "Pallas-Schlegel
School" and is included in Haffer's volume because
of his great systematic activity during the early part
of this century and to clarify his role in the devel-
opment of ideas relating to systematics and the spe-
cies concept, which are very different from those of
the Seebohm-Hartert School.
Ornithologen-Briefe has three main sections. In the
first, Haffer discusses the Seebohm-Hartert School
and describes how its members interacted closely
during the period of about 1880 to1950 to develop
avian systematics and the species concept that had
major influences well beyond the bounds of orni-
thology. Although Hartert and Stresemann were the
central persons holding this school together for most
of this period, Rensch and Mayr were the major the-
orists.
The second part, which forms the bulk of the vol-
ume, contains the correspondence (mainly in Ger-
man) between Stresemann and Hartert, Klein-
schmidt, Hellmayr, and Mayr. Haffer presents an
overview to each set of letters so that the non-Ger-
man reader can obtain a good summary of the let-
ters. Not all letters between these workers were pub-
lished, and strictly personal matters and ephemeral
material may have been left out of some published
letters. However, the published letters do not contain
only scientific discussions, but also numerous com-
ments on family life and remarks on current political
matters that provide a view into the lives of these
people. This is especially interesting for the period
1935 to 1950, such as the letter from Stresemann to
Mayr dated 12 April 1934 and mailed from Italy in
which he commented on the developments of the
"n[ational]-s[ozialistische] Programm" in Germany,
stating clearly that he did not feel free to write these
comments from Germany because of "Der scharfen
Zensur...," and the long series of letters between
Stresemann and Mayr on conditions in Germany af-
ter World War II and the AOU program of sending
care packages to European ornithologists. A letter
from Stresemann to Mayr on 5 February 1939 stated
that Fritz Frank, a doctoral student, had obtained the
first electron micrographs of feathers. The electron
micrograph published by Frank (Journal fiir Orni-
thologie 87:426-423, 1939) almost certainly is the first
such illustration of biological material.
The third part contains biographical notes of 12
people, including all of the central figures in this his-
tory, except for Henry Seebohm and Walter Roths-
child. An excellent biography of the latter can be
found in Miriam Rothschild's Dear Lord Rothschild,
but a good historical analysis still does not exist for
Henry Seebohm, who has not received the recogni-
tion he deserves. A brief biography is given for Carl
Hellmayr, who was another key person in the See-
bohm-Hartert School and an important avian sys-
tematist during the first four decades of this century,
but is still almost unknown to most European and
North American ornithologists. A biography is also
provided for Otto Kleinschmidt, who is widely
known for his Formenkreis concept, although most
systematists do not realize that he was a non-evolu-
tionary, essentialistic typologist and contributed lit-
tle to the development of systematic theory. A two-
page reminiscence of Leonard Sanford was written
by Mayr. However, a more complete biography is still
needed of this remarkable man. The biography of Er-
win Stresemann should be read in conjunction with
the tribute to Stresemann (Journal fiir Ornithologie,
114:455-500, 1973).
The forth and last part of Haffer's volume con-
tains appendices, and although many readers
might overlook this section, it contains some very
interesting gems such as a previously unpublished
account of Stresemann's expedition of 1910-1912 to
the Moluccas in Indonesia. The letter from Profes-
sor Otto Koehler to Professor Stubbe relates to a fra-
cas that arose in the Berlin Academy of Science be-
cause of a review published by Stresemann of a
Festschrift for Otto Kleinschmidt in which Strese-
mann stated quite correctly that Kleinschmidt was
a typological essentialist. More interesting is a let-
ter from Stresemann to Professor Clara, Universitkit
Leipzig, dated 28 May 1940, in which he strongly
recommended Ernst Mayr, then in the United
States, for the position as Director of the Museum
ftir Tierkunde in Dresden (Mayr's hometown since
1917 until leaving for the U.S.), including the sug-
gestion that Mayr could travel to Germany via Ja-
pan. Although the prewar correspondence between
Stresemann and Mayr lasted until fall 1941, there is
no comment about Stresemann's recommendation
in any of their letters.
Haffer traces the history of another important or-
nithological development in this book, namely the
rise of the "New Avian Biology." In August 1914,
Professor W. Ktikenthal invited Erwin Stresemann,
then at the age of 25 and well before he received his
Ph.D., to prepare the Aves volume for the Handbuch
der Zoologie. This volume (1927-1934) was clearly
Stresemann's opus magnum and is the most impor-
tant single-volume compilation of ornithology ever
published. In a letter to Hartert, a discouraged Stre-
semann expressed the belief that his Aves volume
probably would never be published because of the
recent death of Ktikenthal. In 1920, Stresemann had
delivered the first installment of his manuscript to
Ktikenthal, by now director of the Berlin Museum,
who was so impressed with it that he offered Stre-
semann the just-vacated position of curator of
birds. Hence, the fortunate invitation to prepare the
Aves volume and his excellent first installment were
central to the development of Stresemann's career
as discussed earlier by Haffer. But there was anoth-
er significant outcome of this invitation, as pointed
out by Haffer, in that Stresemann became con-
vinced in the 1910s that the future of ornithology
lay in the development of functional studies, the
new avian biology. His belief was expressed in the
coverage of materials in the Aves volume and in the
assignment of dissertation topics to his students
during the 1920s and 1930s. Many of these doctoral
theses were published in the Journalfiir Ornithologie,
making it the most respected ornithological journal
prior to World War II. But there is still the interest-
ing question of how Stresemann's ideas about the
new avian biology spread to other ornithologists
around the world. Haffer speaks of "The Strese-
mann School," but I would contend that although
many of Stresemann's students completed excellent
theses, they did not constitute a school in the usual
sense of the term. Perhaps the better term is "the
Stresemann circle." Stresemann, being at the Berlin
Museum, was not able to develop laboratory facil-
ities, did no actual functional studies himself, and
was not able to be the primary or formal supervisor
of his students. Moreover, because of the traditions
of German academia, it was not possible for him to
obtain positions for his students in universities.
Hence, if one examines the careers of Stresemann's
students in Germany, they were restricted to posi-
tions in museums, zoological gardens, Gymnasia,
etc., and they did not continue research in the spe-
ciality of their doctoral theses. Although everyone
knows about the Aves volume, the distribution of
Stresemann's volume was limited. Haffer states that
536 copies of the 2,200 printed were sold by 1934,
and that 156 additional copies were sold by 1944
when the remainder were destroyed by fire at the
printer's in Leipzig. A total of only 692 copies was
sold. Moreover, I suspect that outside of German-
speaking areas, this volume is more often looked at
and cited than actually read. I surmise that the
spread of Stresemann's ideas on the new avian bi-
ology outside of Germany was largely a vague os-
mosis by way of a knowledge about the Aves vol-
ume, an appreciation of the theses of his students
published in the Journal fiir Ornithologie, and the
comments of a few of his students, mainly Ernst
Mayr, who worked outside of Germany. Indeed, an
interesting topic in the history of ornithology
would be the origins of ideas about the new avian
biology and their development up to the two-vol-
ume Biology and Comparative Physiology of Birds
(1960-1961) edited by A. J. Marshall, and the nine-
volume Avian Biology (1975-1993) edited by D.S.
Farner and J.R. King.
Ornithologen-Briefe is well illustrated with photo-
graphs, many not previously published. The best
one, in my opinion, is the young Ernst Mayr in 1924,
as a medical student, hovering over a well-dissected
cadaver with a colleague. Unfortunately, the book
lacks a list of illustrations so that it is often difficult
to find again a figure previously seen.
Anyone with the slightest interest in the history
of ornithology will find Ornithologen-Briefe a most
valuable book--a delight to read for the first time
and a gem to come back to time and time again.
Each reading uncovers new and interesting bits of
information that add to the understanding of the
historical development of ornithology during the
first two-thirds of this century. Jtirgen Haffer is to
be congratulated by ornithologists and historians
alike for the long and painstaking efforts that he put
into this volume. Similar congratulations and
thanks should go to J. H61zinger, editor of (kologie
der VSgel, and all others involved in making docu-
ments and photographs available and in the suc-
cessful publication of this volume. Ornithologen-
Briefe is a book that I enjoyed thoroughly and one
that I can recommend strongly to all ornithologists
and historians of science.
I express my appreciation to Ernst Mayr, Domi-
nique G. Homberger, Karl-L. Schuchmann, James L.
Gulledge, and J. Haffer for discussions during the
preparation of this review and comments on the
manuscript.--WALTER J. BOCK, Department of Biolog-
ical Sciences, Columbia University, 1200 Amsterdam Av-
enue, New York, New York 10027, USA.
Avian Conservation: Research and Manage-
ment.--Edited by John M. Marzluff and Rex Salla-
banks. 1998. Island Press, Washington, D.C. x + 563
pp., 27 figures. ISBN 1-55-963-569. Cloth, $55.00.--In
1977, Stan Temple convened the first major sympo-
sium on conservation of endangered birds (Endan-
gered Species: Management Techniques for Preserving
Threatened Species ). In that symposium, 54 authors fo-
cused their attention on the reasons why species de-
cline and sought to document the methods being ap-
plied to the task of species recovery. Nineteen years
later, at a joint meeting of the American Ornitholo-
gists' Union and the Raptor Research Foundation in
Boise, Idaho, John Marzluff and Rex Sallabanks
brought together researchers and managers to re-
view current research activities to conserve birds
and "identify information gaps that need to be filled
if we are to effectively conserve birds." Marzluff and
Sallabanks chose to broaden the scope of their sym-
posium well beyond that of Temple, who focused on
saving species threatened with extinction. Marzluff
and Sallabanks dealt with a much wider variety of
species, and the collected papers put more emphasis
on habitat-based management rather than the clini-
cal focus so often found in the habitat-based man-
agement approach documented in Temple's classic
work. Avian Conservation has 31 chapters and treats
450 species and 17 countries. Geographic coverage of
North America is broad, from Maine to Hawaii and
Quebec to British Columbia, but there is a decided
western flavor with repeated references to western
research strategies. No eastern and only four mid-
western research strategies are discussed. Reflecting
the recent emphasis on status of Neotropical mi-
grants, more than 35 references in the index are to
the Neotropical region and even more to Neotropical
migrants.
The 31 chapters, about half of which were pre-
sented in Boise, are organized into seven groups: (1)
an introduction in which the current status of avian
conservation biology is reviewed, (2) techniques for
conserving and monitoring birds, (3) approaches for
conserving endangered and sensitive species, (4)
conservation in forested landscapes, (5) conservation
in non-forested and urban landscapes, (6) global var-
iation in conservation needs, and (7) a management
perspective entitled "Relevance of Conservation Re-
search to Land Managers."
In the first chapter, Marzluff and Sallabanks pro-
vide an overview of past efforts to save species and
suggest future directions in avian conservation.
Their plea for more large-area, long-term studies is
valid. They suggest that this could be accomplished
by researchers stringing together a series of related
studies over a period of years. This task is not easy
but can be accomplished and be extremely produc-
tive, as the work of Gordon Orians and his students
on Red-winged Blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus),
Russell Balda, and his colleagues and students on
Pinyon Jays (Gymnorhinus cyanocephalus), and Glen
Woolfenden and others on Florida Scrub-Jays (Aphel-
ocoma coerulescens) has demonstrated. An alternative
model is for an agency or other source of research
funding to direct its attention toward a species or re-
lated group of species. Perhaps the best example of
this approach is the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's
40-year research commitment to ducks and geese.
Fran James' cogent remarks in Chapter 2 on the
growing pains of avian conservation biology caution
us to stick to the facts. She points out the necessity,
oftentimes ignored, of conducting bias-free science,
free of special interest influences. But perhaps her
most important admonition is about the danger of
equating correlational studies with cause and effect.
Her work should be read by everyone in the field.
The chapter by Viilard and his coauthors on the
contributions of spatial modeling to avian conser-
vation points out the need for quality data and the
value of a hierarchical approach to addressing re-
search questions. More space could have been de-
voted to the need for accuracy assessment of our
modeling efforts of long-term viability of bird pop-
ulations, as well as to avian responses to habitat ma-
nipulations. Their point that driving forces operating
at the site level may be inconsequential at the level of
ecoregions cannot be emphasized enough. However,
in seeking clues to needed recovery actions, a tem-
poral perspective is also needed. Reasons for the his-
torical decline of a species may not be the cause for
current losses or weak recovery. Recent findings by
James Estes and colleagues that current declines in a
recovered population of sea otters (Enhydra lutris)
were attributable to killer whales (Orcincus orca), a
species for which there was no historical record of
feeding on sea otters, is a well-documented case in
point.
Martin Raphael and coauthors provide a nice ex-
ample of the use of geographic information systems
in modeling a spatially explicit population response
of the Northern Spotted Owl (Strix occidentalis caur-
ina) to different scenarios of timber harvest and
growth. Retrospective analysis of recovery efforts
for a species can be insightful, and the endangered
Hawaiian avifauna provides a great opportunity for
such studies. Villard and Maurere use the Palila (Lox-
ioides bailleui) to illustrate the use of radio telemetry
and the Akepa (Loxops coccineus) to document the
usefulness of geographic information systems as a
conservation tool. Black uses the Hawaiian Goose
(Branta sandvicensis) to illustrate recent efforts to re-
cover populations of duck and geese. What lessons
might we have learned from a detailed retrospective
analysis of the decline of the Hawaiian Crow (Corvus
hawaiiensis)? Valuable insights in species conserva-
tion are provided in the chapter by Scott Derrickson,
Steve Beissinger, and Noel Snyder on directions in
endangered species research. They provide a valu-
able review of research techniques for conserving
species and examples of successes and failures. I
would have liked to see this chapter expanded to in-
clude more species and a detailed discussion of the
examples provided. Rodda et al.'s chapter on the avi-
fauna of the Marianas Islands was instructive re-
garding the threats faced by island faunas and the
speed at which populations can be lost.
The introductions to each of the seven groups of
papers were helpful in that they provided transitions
to as well as overviews of what was to come. In the
groupings of papers on conservation in forested
landscapes, the wide-ranging review of the effect of
fragmentation was well presented. Haufler's presen-
tation of a strategy for bird research in the western
United States could have been complemented by
similar chapters for southeastern, northeastern, and
midwestern forests. However, the introductory dis-
cussion of future directions for avian conservation
helped to make up for this lack of evenness in geo-
graphic coverage. The chapter "Conservation in
Nonforested and Urban Landscapes" in Part V cov-
ered seabirds, shrubland, grassland, urban environ-
ments, and species nicely. A chapter on wetlands and
their associated shorebird populations was badly
needed. Given that wetland habitats are among the
most threatened worldwide, it seems a major over-
sight, one of the few I found. I was delighted to see
the group of papers on global variation in conser-
vation needs.
All too frequently, North American editors of con-
ference proceedings tend be parochial in their choice
of authors. However, Marzluff and Sallabanks did an
excellent job of bringing in authors from around the
world to provide a global perspective to avian con-
servation research and management. Such a per-
spective can only improve research and management
efforts in the United States. Throughout this volume,
authors repeatedly state the need for closer com-
munication among researchers and managers, not
only at the end of a project, but from its inception.
Several point out that managers may provide per-
spectives that would make the questions we pose
more relevant to management activities and thus
should be involved from the start of a project. The
group of papers on the relevance of conservation to
land managers provides excellent insights on how
relationships between researchers and managers can
be strengthened. Unfortunately, all but one of the in-
dividuals writing these chapters were researchers or
research administrators. Although they provide
valuable insights, it has been my experience that
managers often view things quite differently.
Many of the chapters provide information on re-
search and/or information needs. Despite the vari-
ety of species and habitats reviewed in this book,
many of the research needs were the same. Frequent-
ly identified needs were (1) more information on
habitat associations, (2) more information on limit-
ing factors, and (3) when do you give up? The last is
truly a tough question, and one that was not an-
swered here. For example, is the mongoose (Herpestes
auropunctatus) so ubiquitous that we are incapable of
eliminating it over the area occupied by the Hawai-
ian Goose? Thus, are we left with a continuation of
our 50-year put-and-take program? Like so many
questions of this type, we have yet to conduct the
studies that would provide us with answers.
The discussions of how research can be made more
effective for conservation should be instructive for
managers and researchers alike. The comments
throughout the text on the features of research and
management have led to improvement in conserva-
tion efforts and should prove helpful to others
whether they are engaged in single-species or eco-
system approaches to conservation. Rodda et al.'s
discussions of the problems associated with obtain-
ing replicable population estimates were instructive,
but they failed to consider the issues of varying qual-
ity of observers, observer-training efforts (or lack
thereof), and the variable use of passive and active
sampling techniques by observers.
I found only limited cross referencing among
chapters. It remains largely for the reader to look for
common threads, a task made easier by the many
similar section headings. In a similar vein, a book of
this nature normally has a concluding chapter in
which the assorted contributions are reviewed, syn-
thesized, and future research guidelines provided.
However, much of this was done in the individual
chapters on past approaches and future directions
for avian conservation biology and Fran James' con-
tribution on the growing pains of avian conservation
biology. The repeated appearance of the same sec-
tion headings throughout the book, e.g. features of
research that improved conservation and making re-
search effective for conservation, linked the chapters
and provided a sense of continuity to the book. Still,
there could have been more extensive cross referenc-
ing of chapters.
Overall, I think the editors did an excellent job of
putting together papers that provide us with guid-
ance for future research and management on birds.
The assembled group of authors was noteworthy in
that only two had also participated in the 1977 sym-
posium in Madison, Wisconsin. Also notable was the
participation of forest industry scientists, something
not observed at the Wisconsin meeting. Well orga-
nized, the book was a good review of selected man-
agement and conservation practices. The breadth of
its taxonomic and geographic coverage was truly im-
pressive. I recommend this book for scientists and
managers working with birds and their habitats. It
should be in all university libraries as well as those
of biological field stations and research stations
worldwide.--J. MICHAEL SCOTT, United States Geolog-
ical Survey, Department of Fish and Wildlife Resources,
University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho 83844, USA.
The Auk 116(3):866-868, 1999
Population Limitation in Birds.--Ian Newton.
1998. Academic Press, London. x + 597 pp., 19 black-
and-white drawings, 109 figures, 61 tables. ISBN 0-
12-517366-0. Paper, $49.95.--Population limitation in
birds has been a central focus of field ornithologists
in the 20th century. David Lack brought attention to
this endeavor in his classic text Natural Regulation of
Animal Numbers (1954). Since that time, numerous
debates have waxed and waned in ornithology.
Through it all, field ornithologists have ploddingly
stayed focused on the limits of bird population size.
This doggedly empirical approach to understanding
population regulation is the foundation of Newton's
book.
The volume of research on bird population limits
would make it easy, perhaps likely, for a compilation
to become muddled in the contradictions and mi-
nutia that the literature represents. An impressive
feature of this book is its organization and readabil-
ity. The user-friendly style, however, does not result
from diluted content. The text provides a rich array
of detail and nuance that could only come from a life-
time of experience with detailed field studies. Ty-
pographical errors are rare and confusing sentences
or presentations rarer still. Main themes are adhered
to closely and examples are squarely on topic.
I had only two substantive complaints about the
book. First, many of the concepts and interpretations
are familiar. For the vast evidence it reports on pop-
ulation limitation, the book presents few new con-
cepts and little novel interpretation of the data. In
many instances, this conservative interpretation is
probably to the author's credit. That is, the emphasis
is on interpreting the accumulated evidence and not
on inventing new terminology. Nonetheless, I found
that it made reading some sections straight through
a bit tedious. This problem is exacerbated in spots by
the repeated use of a limited number of species as
examples (e.g. Red Grouse [Lagopus lagopus], Eur-
asian Oystercatcher [Haematopus ostralegus], and
Great Tit [Parus major]). Although these examples are
relevant and certainly among the best available, I
think that the repetition reduces their impact.
My second complaint is the lack of mathematical
development for many of the conceptual models that
underpin the data presented. Most models are pre-
sented graphically, which effectively demonstrates
the general concepts. In a number of cases, however,
the interpretation and understanding would have
been enhanced by an explicit mathematical presen-
tation of the models. Some such models are logistic
growth, predator-prey, and metapopulation models.
It should be noted that the author addresses this
complaint directly in the Preface and indicates that
the mathematical treatments were intentionally
omitted to increase the book's audience.
The book is comprised of a preface, 16 chapters di-
vided into a preview chapter and three major parts
(Behavior and Density Regulation, Natural Limiting
Factors, and Human Impacts), a bibliography, and a
substantial index. The preview chapter describes the
focus of the book and the rational for focusing on
birds. For example, Newton argues "Because no pop-
ulation increases to infinity and species only rarely
go extinct, regulation can be assumed to occur...."
Thus, readers should not expect the book to debate
whether population regulation (and, by implication,
density dependence) is of primary importance. Rath-
er, the book is a search for empirical evidence of the
prevalent mechanisms that regulate population
numbers. Much of the theoretical and conceptual de-
velopments are of an equilibrium nature. This bias
likely reflects the preponderance of equilibrium ex-
planations in the literature as much as any bias of the
author.
Part one of the book deals with behavior and den-
sity regulation and is comprised of 111 pages divid-
ed into Chapters 2 to 6. The first of these chapters,
"Social Systems and Status," is relatively brief and
explores how social rank influences reproduction
and resource acquisition. Compared with later chap-
ters, it has few examples from the literature. The
main conclusions are that, generally, adults domi-
nate juveniles and males dominate females for access
to resources. The next chapter, "Habitat and Density
Regulation," documents how habitat quality can set
an upper bound to the number of individuals living
in an area. The implication is that if population size
exceeds that limit, then competitive interactions will
decide which individuals will survive or breed in the
area. The theoretical basis of the chapter is primarily
the ideal-free model of habitat selection. There are
also discussions of other factors that affect the rela-
tionship between habitat quality and density, such as
territoriality, season, habitat loss, and synchronous
versus sequential habitat use. Of these factors, the
presentation of data on percent of adults that were
nonterritorial and nonbreeding was particularly in-
teresting (21 species from 24 studies). Estimates
ranged from 0 to 72%, with most between 40 and
70%. That's a lot of nonbreeding birds!
The importance of the number of nonterritorial
nonbreeders presented in Chapter 3 is immediately
evident in the next chapter, "Territorial Behavior and
Density Limitation" (and is another example of the
thoughtful presentation of this book). Here, Newton
focuses primarily on empirical results of removal ex-
periments (74 studies on 53 species). Separate dis-
cussions are provided for passerines, grouse, rap-
tors, waterfowl, waders, and seabirds. These discus-
sions clearly demonstrate that territoriality can limit
breeding density but also that the relationships
among habitat quality, territoriality, and density are
complex. Chapter 5 focuses on the importance and
detection of density dependence. The three main
types of evidence examined are 63 life-table studies
(particularly 22 that employ key-factor analysis), ex-
perimental manipulations of density, and studies
that document spatial patterns in density. All three
lines of evidence provide support for density depen-
dence, but plenty of evidence also exists for density-
independent effects. Newton's discussions of why
density dependence may not be stabilizing where it
is detected, and why density dependence may some-
times not be detected where it is important, also are
interesting.
I felt that Chapter 6, "Habitat Fragments and Me-
tapopulations," was the lone disappointment in this
book. My disappointment, in part, may reflect the
proliferation of conceptual development in this field
and a dearth of empirical evidence. The chapter
seems out of place, but it is not clear where it would
fit better. It perhaps should have been incorporated
into another chapter. The majority of data presented
are from populations that occur in habitat fragments.
Specifically, most of the data address the issue of
patch size and bird density. The formal treatment of
metapopulations was slight. Metapopulation theory
and models are described in the text, but the detailed
graphical treatment of conceptual issues evident in
the other chapters is noticeably absent. Also absent
are the detailed literature summaries and case stud-
ies of the other chapters.
The second section focuses on natural limiting fac-
tors and is comprised of 230 pages in seven chapters
(Chapters 7 to 13). The first chapter in this section,
"Food Supply," covers a topic that may be the most
obvious and well-studied factor affecting bird pop-
ulations. Even though relationships between food
supply and bird populations are well known, New-
ton does an admirable job of accumulating the evi-
dence. For instance, this chapter contains reviews of
the relationship between food supply and breeding
performance (32 studies) and bird numbers (ca. 79
studies). Also included are reviews of the incidence
of starvation (16 studies), causes of mortality (11
studies), and causes of population declines in Euro-
pean farmland birds (16 studies). The interpretation
of these results will probably not reveal too many
surprises, but the large number of studies compiled
makes this chapter one of the most valuable in the
book. In addition, the details and circumstances of
case studies keep the text interesting.
In many ways Chapter 8, "Nest-sites," is the flip-
side of the arguments made in Chapter 3. That is, if
habitat is augmented with the addition of nest sites,
then breeding density increases. This conclusion is
based largely on interpretation of the 36 studies
where nest-cavity availability was experimentally
manipulated. The next chapter, "Predation," in-
cludes brief discussions of numerical and functional
response of predators, density-dependent and den-
sity-independent predation, and compensatory and
additive mortality; the presentation of these topics is
more conceptual than quantitative. This chapter con-
tains some well-presented examples, notably New-
ton's own work on Eurasian Sparrowhawks (Accipiter
nisus). In addition, experimental evidence from 27
studies is used to show increased breeding success,
postbreeding survival, and subsequent breeding
density as a result of predator exclusion.
Chapter 10, "Parasites and Pathogens," was my fa-
vorite chapter in this section, perhaps because I
know the least about the topic. The chapter begins
with a description of the most common micropara-
sites, macroparasites, and brood parasites of birds.
Of these, the brood parasite section seemed out of
place with the rest of the chapter. The chapter's three
main sections are effects of parasites on individual
performance, effects of parasites on populations, and
other conservation problems. Prior to reading it, I ex-
pected this chapter to be descriptive and fairly data-
poor. To my surprise, however, it contains numerous
case studies, a table of about 30 studies that examine
the effects of parasites on breeding performance, and
another table of equal size for studies that document
large-scale disease outbreaks in full-grown birds.
These studies provide a glimpse of the influence of
parasites and pathogens on populations and their
potential to cause future conservation problems.
The evidence presented on the effects of weather
(Chapter 11) is not as strong as the experimental ev-
idence in some other chapters. This difference un-
doubtedly stems from the difficulty of incorporating
weather into an experimental design. Consequently,
evidence for weather effects is comprised mostly of
case studies where weather has been shown to cause
declines in bird numbers. Despite the logistical dif-
ficulties associated with understanding the effects of
weather, the numerous examples used make an ef-
fective case for its importance as a limit on bird pop-
ulations. The chapter also provides some interesting
examples of how weather can cause selective mor-
tality within and among populations.
By comparison, more data are provided on inter-
specific competition (Chapter 12) than on any other
topic in the book, with the possible exception of food
supply. Commendably, the evidence for effects of
competition is interpreted with careful reference to
the design of the study and variables measured. Cir-
cumstantial evidence for competition is clearly dis-
tinguished from the far rarer experimental evidence.
Newton provides a table of 29 studies that manipu-
lated resources or food to study the effects of com-
petition on individuals. Attention is also drawn to
other indirect biotic interactions that could errone-
ously result in apparent competition. This section on
apparent competition is a clever segue to the topic of
Chapter 13, "Interactions Between Different Limit-
ing Factors." This chapter provides several interest-
ing examples of the relationships among factors de-
scribed in the previous six chapters. The main mes-
sage of this chapter is cautionary. Most of the exper-
iments reviewed in the book examined the effects of
a single limiting factor. However, the magnitude of
such effects may be strongly influenced by other fac-
tors that are rarely controlled or measured.
The final 101 pages of the book concentrate on hu-
man effects and are divided into three chapters.
Chapter 14 focuses on hunting and pest control. The
hunting portion contains a list of hunting strategies
but focuses primarily on maximum sustained yield
and studies that have tried to estimate it. Also, the
importance of knowing what portion of hunting
mortality is additive and what portion is compen-
satory is demonstrated. The section on pest control
is primarily a list of pest-control strategies and ex-
amples of the use of some of them on Woodpigeons
(Columba palumbus), Quelea (Quelea quelea), and rap-
tors.
Because I have paid scant attention to recent work
on pesticides and pollutants, I found the treatment
of this topic in Chapter 15 particularly compelling.
The subjects covered are diverse and range from or-
ganochlorine pesticides to oil spills to global warm-
ing. Newton does a fine job of explaining the differ-
ent pesticide and pollutant issues that brings a sense
of unity to these diverse topics. Tables summarize 16
studies that demonstrated mortality over large areas
as a result of pesticide application and 9 that mea-
sured the immediate effects of pesticides on bird
numbers. The examples are particularly memorable;
e.g. it is hard to conceive of using pesticides to in-
tentionally kill up to one billion Quelea a year. Even
well-worn examples like eggshell thinning and DDT
are insightful. In particular, I wonder what was so
controversial about the ban on DDT given the clear
evidence of its effects? Perhaps in 30 years I will be
asking the same question about burning fossil fuels
and the effects of global warming.
Chapter 16 is devoted to documenting the corre-
lates of extinction in birds. The chapter contains a ta-
ble of 127 species of birds that have gone extinct since
1600. Almost all were driven to extinction by human
actions. Newton's conclusion in the ultimate chapter
is that for most birds, the limits of their populations
will be determined by human actions. The range of
bird population sizes, from rarity to superabun-
dance, will result from our own patterns of resource
use. Although it is hard to argue with this assess-
ment, it is an ironic conclusion given the effort we
have expended on understanding other mechanisms
of population limitation.
In summary, this book is a well-written compila-
tion of empirical evidence on factors that limit bird
populations. Anyone interested in the determinants
of bird numbers or population biology will find this
book enjoyable and useful. Researchers and manag-
ers who work with bird populations will find it to be
an invaluable source of many topics in bird popula-
tion biology. All self-respecting university libraries
need to have a copy. The book may hold the most
value, however, for upper-division undergraduates
and graduate students who can use it as an entryway
to field ornithology.--JEFFREY E KELLY, United States
Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, 2205
Columbia SE, Albuquerque, New Mexico 87106, USA.
The Auk 116(3):868-870, 1999
Parrots: A Guide to Parrots of the World.--Tony
Juniper and Mike Parr. 1998. Yale University Press,
New Haven, Connecticut. 584 pp., 88 color plates, 352
maps. ISBN 0-300-07453-0. Cloth, $55.00.--This vol-
ume seeks to provide customs agents, wildlife en-
forcement officials, and field observers with a com-
prehensive identification guide to the species and
subspecies of parrots. The text provides range maps
and descriptions designed to facilitate identification
and summarizes the current state of knowledge on
habitat, behavior, diet, reproductive biology, and
conservation status of each of the 352 parrot species.
The plates contain more than 1,300 color illustrations
of all species and nearly every well-differentiated
subspecies, both perched and in flight. Although the
text does a good job of tackling its stated objectives,
the contrasting styles of the five illustrators and the
errors discussed below reduce the volume's utility as
an identification guide and its aesthetic appeal.
The book begins with a 20-page introduction that
summarizes taxonomic relationships, classification,
natural history, conservation status, threats, and cap-
tive breeding. By design, this wide breadth of topics
is not covered in much depth, but the introduction
provides a well-written summary that contains
many interesting examples. The sections on habitat
loss and the live-bird trade realistically address
these complex issues and nicely summarize the ma-
jor difficulties faced by parrots and parrot conser-
vationists. Given this, it is disappointing that the dis-
cussion on captive breeding ends with the odd and
indefensible statement, "Once the wild birds are
gone, so has the reason to conserve their habitat and
once the habitat is gone, the birds can never be put
back."
The worst transgression of this introductory sec-
tion is that almost none of the supporting details can
be tracked to their original sources. Statements like
"...Brotogeris parakeets of South America apparent-
ly show an association with trees in the Bombaca-
ceae..." go unreferenced, leaving the reader to pick
through the references at the end of each species ac-
count to find the original source. In addition, of the
12 references cited in the introductory sections, one-
third of them are either not in the bibliography or are
cited incorrectly.
The 1,300 illustrations in the plates represent the
most comprehensive set of parrot images ever as-
sembled. Unfortunately, the five artists made no at-
tempt to standardize their styles. As a result, some
illustrations are heavily shaded and show nearly ev-
ery feather edge, whereas others appear two-dimen-
sional and cartoon-like. This detracts from the vol-
ume's aesthetic appeal and may constrain its useful-
ness as an identification guide. In a worst-case sce-
nario, inexperienced observers may use general
feather texture as an important field mark and make
grave errors. The art work by Franklin is well done.
For instance, the plates covering the green-and-red
Aratinga conures, both perched and in flight, should
greatly aid identification of this very difficult group
of species that are common in captivity and as es-
capees in the United States. The remaining four art-
ists had great difficulty correctly capturing the
shapes of parrots in flight. For one artist, this prob-
lem extended to the perched birds and resulted in
the depiction of some rather oddly shaped parakeets
and Amazon parrots. In addition, plates by at least
two artists contain either unrefined field sketches or
birds with white areas where the painting was not
finished.
On a more serious note, some plates contain errors
of varying magnitudes. Illustrations of birds in flight
often have proportionally longer tails and different
body-plumage colors than illustrations of the same
species perched. Some of the specific errors include
the bright blue cap on the flying Cobalt-winged Par-
akeet (Brotogeris cyanoptera), a mark that appears di-
agnostic on the illustration but is not particularly
visible on flying birds; the depiction of Salmon-crest-
ed (Cacatua moluccensis) and White (Cacatua alba)
cockatoos as equally white on the back, when nearly
all individuals of the former are clearly pinker than
the latter; the white and grayish facial skin of the
Red-bellied Macaw (Orthopsittaca [Ara] manilata),
whereas the text rightly states that the yellow facial
skin separates this from all other small macaws; the
solid blue tail and nape of the Blue-headed Macaw
(Propyrrhura [Ara] coluni), when the central tail feath-
ers are mostly red and green and the nape is green;
and the depiction of Gray-cheeked (Brotogeris
phrrhopterus) and Plain-green (B. tirica) parakeets as
having the same tail length, when the tail of Plain-
green is twice the length of Gray-cheeked. Finally,
the characteristics of the two subspecies of "Canary-
winged Parakeets" (recently split into two species by
the AOU) have been confounded on the illustrations.
An illustration showing a bird that has all the char-
acteristics of Yellow-chevroned Parakeet (Brotogeris
[versicolurus] chiriri) and the white flight feathers di-
agnostic of White-winged Parakeet (B. [v.] versicolu-
rus) is labeled B. [v.] versicolurus, whereas a bird that
looks like a White-winged except with no white in
the flight feathers is labeled B. [v.] chiriri. Because
these species have just been split, and both birds oc-
cur in Florida and California, extensive hybridiza-
tion between them might be taken as evidence that
they are conspecific. Unfortunately, anyone relying
on these illustrations would consider all of the birds
to be hybrids, when in fact observations in Miami
suggest that there is little or no hybridization
(Bright-Smith 1999).
Each of the 352 species accounts includes the fol-
lowing sections: "Name, .... Other Names," "Identi-
fication, .... Voice, .... Distribution and Status," "Ecol-
ogy, .... Sex / Age, .... Measurements," "Geographical
Variation," and a range map. For the English names
it is not apparent what standard was used, because
the names do not exactly match those of Forshaw
(1989), Sibley and Monroe (1990), Clements (1991),
del Hoyo et al. (1997), or AOU (1998). The odd mix-
ture of names chosen, and the fact that the alternative
English names and genera are not included in the in-
dex, makes finding species in this book more difficult
than it has to be and adds to the confusion over par-
rot names.
The Identification section nicely summarizes the
diagnostic features useful for separating similar spe-
cies. The authors facilitate identification by present-
ing only diagnostic features here, saving full plum-
age descriptions for the Description section. This
keeps the reader interested in making a quick iden-
tification from getting lost in unnecessary details.
The range maps show much refinement over those
presented in Forshaw (1989) and apparently reflect
much new work. These maps, useful as they are,
could have been improved by shading to indicate the
ranges of the different subspecies as presented in the
text. This may have helped customs agents easily de-
termine source nations for subspecies and alert them
to re-exportation of subspecies from countries not in
their native ranges.
Much work on the ecology, behavior, and conser-
vation of parrots has been published in the last dec-
ade, and this new information is well represented in
the text. New species, new nest descriptions, and the
latest in conservation status and threats also are pre-
sented. This summary of new literature represents
the most valuable ornithological contribution of the
book. Unfortunately, the decision to group all refer-
ences at the end of each species account makes it dif-
ficult to access the original sources.
For the most part, the text achieves its goals of
summarizing the current state of knowledge on par-
rots, but the disquieting mixture of artwork and the
illustration errors may limit its appeal and utility.
The complete collection of flying parrot illustrations
is potentially very useful, but these should be further
checked for accuracy, especially for Old World and
Australasian species with which I am less familiar.
The summary of the last decade of literature on par-
rots, and the low price, will earn this book a place in
the libraries of most colleges and parrot afficionados,
but the difficulty of accessing the original sources
may limit its utility for ornithologists. Because it is
at the upper limit of what is comfortable to carry in
the field, Parrots likely will be used at home or in the
library, where it will face tough competition from the
strong text and fine artwork of Forshaw (1989) and
del Hoyo et al. (1997).--DONALD J. BRIGHT-SMITH,
Duke University, Department of Zoology, Durham, North
Carolina 27708, USA.
LITERATURE CITED
AMERICAN ORNITHOLOGISTS' UNION. 1998. Check-
list of North American Birds, 7th ed. American
Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.
BRIGHT-SMITH, D. J. 1999. White-winged Parakeet
and Yellow-chevroned Parakeet. In The birds of
North America (A. Poole and E Gill, Eds.). Acad-
emy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia, and
American Ornithologists' Union, Washington,
D.C.
CLEMENTS, J. E 1991. Birds of the world: A checklist.
Ibis Publishing, Vista, California.
DEL HOYO, J., g. ELLIOTT, AND J. SARGATAL (Eds.).
1997. Handbook of the birds of the world, vol. 4.
Lynx Edicions, Barcelona.
FORSHAW, J. M. 1989. Parrots of the world, 3rd ed.
Lansdowne Press, Melbourne, Australia.
SIBLEY, C. G., AND B. L. MONROE, Jr. 1990. Distribu-
tion and taxonomy of birds of the world. Yale
University Press, New Haven, Connecticut.
The Auk 116(3):870-871, 1999
Colorado Breeding Bird Atlas.--Edited by Hugh
E. Kingery. 1998. Colorado Bird Atlas Project and
Colorado Division of Wildlife, Distributed by Colo-
rado Wildlife Heritage Foundation, Denver, Colora-
do. xi + 636 pp., 16 pp. of color photographs, nu-
merous illustrations and maps. ISBN 0-9668506-0-2.
Cloth, $34.95.--This tome is a worthy reflection of
the monumental effort entailed in collecting breed-
ing-bird data in a 269,360-km 2 state centered on the
Rocky Mountains. It is the culmination of more than
a decade of organization, field work, and writing in-
volving nearly 1,200 atlas workers and 30 authors.
The Colorado atlas will be an indispensable addition
to the libraries of professional and amateur orni-
thologists alike. It is also an important work for west-
ern land and wildlife managers. The book features
252 two-page species accounts and 35 supplemental
species accounts. It also contains chapters on Colo-
rado's ecosystems and environment, changes in Col-
orado habitats since settlement, a history of orni-
thology in the state, and a synopsis of the Colorado
bird atlas project methods and results. Appendices
include block statistics (for the serious student of
bird atlases), species abundances, and a summary of
parasitism by Brown-headed Cowbirds (Molothrus
ater).
The book begins with an overview of the methods
and results of the atlas project. This chapter under-
scores the immense accomplishment of organiza-
tion and dedication required to complete the field
aspect of the project. It provides a clear discussion
of methods and a forthright examination of biases
and limitations. It also summarizes statewide re-
suits of avian abundance and distribution in a num-
ber of table figures and maps. What is the most
common bird in Colorado? Which areas of the state
have the greatest avian diversity? You will find the
answers here.
The "Colorado Environment" familiarizes the
reader with the state and its fascinating diversity of
ecosystems and geographical systems. It features a
colorful photographic folio of habitats, nests, and
young birds. Each of the primary bird habitats of
Colorado is described with concise and accurate
notes on occurrence, dominant species, e]evational
ranges, and structural components. A brief list of
representative birds is also provided for each habitat.
The chapter "Post-settlement Changes to Colora-
do Habitats" puts the atlas results in a historical per-
spective. It offers hypotheses on how some of the ma-
jor systems have been affected by man and how these
changes might have influenced Colorado's avifauna;
e.g. the changes that might have led to the expansion
of Blue Jays (Cyanocitta cristata), the decline of Moun-
tain Plovers (Charadrius montanus), and the increase
of Brown-headed Cowbirds. Although this section
provides some thought-provoking perspectives, the
accounts tend to be speculative and not well refer-
enced.
The heart (and bulk) of the Colorado Atlas is its
species accounts. These accounts generally are
well researched and well presented. The narra-
tives are written in an engaging and relatively jar-
gon-free style, making them equally interesting to
amateur birders and professional biologists. Thir-
ty different authors contributed to these accounts,
and Kingery's editing provides a smooth transi-
tion from one account to another. Occasionally, an
author speculates beyond the data or takes some
liberties with accepted taxonomy; however, as a
rule the accounts are well written and carefully
documented. Each species account features sub-
sections on habitat, breeding, and distribution as
well as some historical perspectives. The inclusion
of a habitat component in this atlas makes it an im-
portant tool for the management of breeding
birds. The relative importance of various ecosys-
tems and habitats is clearly graphed for most spe-
cies. Habitat codes can be easily referenced on the
inside back cover. Tables of breeding phenology
are also provided for most species. These tables
are useful, but because of the way the data were
recorded (only the highest breeding code was re-
corded for each species in a block), they often pro-
vide confusing results. For example, in many of
the tables courtship appears to occur after nesting.
Tables of breeding evidence accompany distribu-
tion maps for most species. Although these maps
are very informative, the shaded blocks obstruct
county lines, making it difficult to determine geo-
graphic locations, especially for more widely dis-
tributed species. The state map on the inside front
cover does, however, help with this problem.
This book, like any document of its size, has some
errors, such as the number of Douglas-fir forest
blocks listed as only seven. However, this type of er-
ror appears to be rare. Classic Colorado bird studies
are used for comparison with the current data, and
referenced works cover more than 100 years of ac-
cumulated knowledge. Unfortunately, some refer-
ences that appear in the text are not in the list of ci-
tations, and a list of personal communications would
have been a welcome addition.
The illustrations by Colorado artist Radeaux are
excellent and add to the flavor of the book. The line
drawings feature combinations of adults, nests, eggs,
nestlings, and fledglings in the appropriate nesting
habitat. Illustrations, particularly of the passerines
and other smaller birds, are well proportioned and
demonstrate attention to detail in form, habitat, and
behavior
Although the atlas is a snap-shot in time of Colo-
rado breeding birds, what a picture it is! It provides
data from more than 1,700 25-km 2 blocks (and what
you do not find in the book, you will be able to find
in the database archive available in spring 1999). The
book reflects some of the fun of atlas-style birding
and the importance of collecting atlas information,
and, although the publication of the atlas is just the
begirming, it marks a right-of-passage for Colorado
ornithology and atlas projects in general. The Colo-
rado Breeding Bird Atlas is a valuable work for orni-
thologists, land and wildlife managers, and amateur
birders. It is a combination of form and function wor-
thy of the fascinating bird life it portrays.--FRANK P.
HOWE, Utah Division of Wildlife Resources, 1594 West
North Temple, Suite 2110, Salt Lake City, Utah 84114,
USA.
The Auk 116(3):871-872, 1999
Manual of Raptors, Pigeons and Waterfowl.--Ed-
ited by Peter A. Beynon. 1996. Iowa State University
Press, Ames. 364 pp. ISBN 0-8138-2876-7. Paper,
$89.95.
Manual of Psittacine Birds.--Edited by Peter A.
Beynon. 1996. Iowa State University Press, Ames. 239
pp. ISBN 0-8138-2349-8. Paper, $72.95.--The scien-
tific editors and many of the chapter authors for both
manuals are credentialed members of the RCVS, and
both manuals were published in Europe under the
auspices of the British Small Animal Veterinary As-
sociation. However, other chapter authors are their
counterparts in other countries, e.g. veterinary cen-
ters in The Netherlands and Germany, The Raptor
Center in the United States, and other centers for in-
ternational zoo medicine, The Wildlife and Wetlands
Trust, and similar organizations. Many of them are
veterinary surgeons, veterinary radiologists, and
other clinicians.
Part 1 of the raptor manual consists of 12 chapters
with a general presentation of the available data base
from observations of the owners of birds conveyed to
the clinician in the form of their field biology obser-
vations, and an assessment of these observations
from the experience of avian veterinary clinicians.
Their clinical assessment is clearly derived from the
success/failure of therapeutic techniques that they
have employed to restore sick and injured birds and
their experience in handling and caring for other-
wise wild birds in the artificial environment of a clin-
ic.
Part 2 of the raptor manual was particularly inter-
esting because of the 11 chapters on medicine. For ex-
ample, the author of the chapter on foot and leg prob-
lems, N.H. Harcourt-Brown, has had more than 20
years of experience in this field of raptor medicine.
The subject of his recent fellowship in veterinary
medicine was the basic and clinical anatomy of the
foot in falcons (Falco) and hawks (Accipiter), based
certainly in part on the numerous species that he has
personally treated because his practice is centered in
one of the most concentrated areas of falconry in
England. He has also treated eagles, e.g. the Tawny
Eagle (Aquila rapax), which apparently is in captivity
in sufficient numbers to be brought to the attention
of avian veterinarians. Owls are also considered, but
not to the same extent as falcons, because they are
not typically used in falconry (although apparently
they are kept as pets by some falconers). A very well-
presented glossary of falconry terms is included as
Appendix 13.1.
Part 3 of the raptor manual considers pigeons
(nine chapters), with at least some special reference
to specific domesticated types used as racing pi-
geons. Part 4 consists of eight chapters on waterfowl,
which is essentially anseriform medicine, although
there is a partial data base on flamingos, guillemots,
and other aquatic birds. The psittacine manual, on
the other hand, consists of 23 chapters, written by a
few of the same authors, but also with several other
specialists with experience in psittacine medicine.
The respective data base in each manual generally
follows the same standard analysis and assessment
of (1) the integument; (2) diseases of the head and
eyes; (3) injury to the wing and leg, including inju-
ries and infections derived from improper perches
and cage habitats; and (4) various systemic diseases.
The latter are considered relative to models (1) for
the nutritional status and functional role(s) of the al-
imentary canal; (2) the respiratory apparatus, in-
cluding infectious diseases and parasite infestations;
(3) reproductive system, nesting, and neonatology;
and (4) various physiological components and their
dysfunctions, including dysphagia and its sequelae,
such as chronic weight loss, vomiting, alimentary di-
arrhea, renal dysfunctions, and other important as-
pects of avian medicine most frequently assessed
from the droppings. Also included is a good assess-
ment of various neurosensory and neuromotor dys-
functions and their importance in avian behavioral
patterns. Other information considers veterinary ex-
perience for individual birds following health-relat-
ed, systemic (anatomical as well as physiological)en-
vironmental effects such as oil spills, but also some-
thing as individualized as health implications and
zoonoses, i.e. infectious diseases naturally transmis-
sible between vertebrates. The latter may be bird to
human, but the authors also include their assessment
of treatments for birds that have been adversely af-
fected by humans, including such hazards as inges-
tion of a fish hook and behavioral imprinting and its
implications for captive birds.
Very important assets in both manuals are the
well-presented tables of data, with abundant rele-
vant information for the clinician/specialist in avian
veterinary medicine as well as the ornithologist.
Both manuals include a formulary in an appendix of
data on the pharmacological agents that may be pre-
scribed for treatment, dosage and routes for thera-
peutic management, and general comments based on
clinical experiences. One table that ! found fascinat-
ing is an initial assessment of the avian patient in the
form of an ornithological history and physical, gen-
erated in part by the bird and in part by its owner.
The index is well organized and very complete in the
raptor manual. I especially appreciated that several
terms are individually cross referenced to the main
body of the text, to an accompanying illustration,
and to the three major avian groups, namely gener-
al/raptor, pigeon, and waterfowl.
Although some might consider the price of the
manuals to be out of range in terms of their imme-
diate interest(s), ! would add that both manuals in-
clude an abundant number of color photographs of
the avian patients, as well as photographs of various
clinical problems (anatomical as well as radiographic
imaging studies) and clinically related laboratory
data (cytology, parasitic infestations, and organ pa-
thology). ! highly recommend both manuals for lab-
oratories in which birds may be held for experimen-
tal purposes. If you have avian pets in captivity, be
certain that your veterinary contacts (veterinary
schools as well as private clinicians) are familiar with
these manuals. If you have a primary interest in birds
as birds, ask your local library to obtain a copy so
that you can enjoy these publications. They are ex-
cellent and well worth the investment.--JAME$ C.
VANDEN BERGE, Northwest Center for Medical Educa-
tion, Indiana University School of Medicine, 3400 Broad-
way, Gary, Indiana 46408, USA.
The Auk 116(3):872-873, 1999
The Birder's Bug Book.--Gilbert Waldbauer. 1998.
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachu-
setts. 290 pp., 16 color plates, 61 figures. ISBN 0-674-
07461-0. Cloth, $27.95.--The alliteration in the title
is pleasant, but more than one birder may wonder
what a "bug book" is supposed to include. More
than anything else, this book is about species inter-
actions, as played out by various combinations of
bug, bird, and human populations. Insect-bird inter-
actions are only part of the text, and though a sim-
plified identification key is present, it is not a natu-
ralist's field guide. The most satisfied readers may be
those birders who enjoy natural history stories and
very lucid connections to the great ideas in biology.
No doubt there will also be fans of Waldbauer's
smooth style that can quote Robert Frost, an 11-year
old grandson, or E. O. Wilson with equal panache. It
is a book for curious, educated folks who may not be
biologists, but might have considered a short course
at a field station along the way. Subscribers to The
Auk might find this book to be a good gift or a
thoughtful provision in a summer guest room. By ex-
plaining myriad species connections, Waldbauer
hopes to increase public appreciation for the players
as well as the evolutionary play.
Readers will instantly notice a profiled bird
sketched in the lower right corner of odd-numbered
pages, which is cleverly animated as the corners are
rolled. Sixty-one other text figures by Jim Nardi are
large, purposeful, and crisply printed, and a center
section features 38 color photographs that are strik-
ing but less informative. The text is mainly presented
as a series of staged battles between various combi-
nations of bugs, birds, and people. Examples are
drawn from around the world; Waldbauer's dedica-
tion to a good story is repeatedly proven by his en-
during swarms of mosquitoes, black flies, and no-see-
ums. He recounts the interactions between Mormon
crickets (Anabrus simplex), western settlers, and Cal-
ifornia Gulls (Larus californicus); insects, farmers,
and Cattle Egrets (Bubulcus ibis); peppered moths
(Biston betularia), industrialists, and birds; butter-
flies, milkweeds, and Blue Jays (Cyanocitta cristata);
malaria, loggers, and the Iiwi (Vestiaria coccinea) on
Hawaii, to name just a few. Along the way, we learn
of European women who wore flea traps around
their necks and that the number of insect families
north of Mexico approximates the number of bird
species (613) and therefore is learnable. There is able
detailing of natural selection, the Hamilton-Zuk hy-
pothesis, mimicry, phoresy, anting, and bioaccumu-
lation before the author concludes with an overview
of Earth's sixth mass extinction, presently driven by
human action. Waldbauer's plea for reducing this
damage is utilitarian and familiar to many of us but
sincerely expressed. If he draws us into this book
based on affinities for birds, bugs, or biology, Wa|d-
bauer's final goal is enriching our view of one seam-
less web of life.--WIlIIAM J. EHMANN, Department of
Biology, Drake University, Des Moines, Iowa 50311,
USA.