Birds in the genus Pitohui carry the potent neurotoxin homobatrachotoxin in their skin and feathers. In this study, I tested whether homobatrachotoxin can repel or kill chewing lice (order Phthiraptera). When individual feather lice were offered a choice of two feathers on which to feed or take shelter, the lice preferred nontoxic feathers to feathers of the most toxic pitohui species, Pitohui dichrous. Moreover, the presence of toxic P. dichrous feathers significantly shortened the life span of captive feather lice. These results suggest that homobatrachotoxin repels and kills lice and may thus protect pitohuis against lice infestation. Received 10 April 1998, accepted 8 February 1999.
Department of Ecology and Evolution, The University of Chicago, 1101 East 57th Street, Chicago, Illinois 60637, USA
SPECIES IN THE AVIAN GENUS PITOHUI carry a
potent alkaloid neurotoxin in their skin and
feathers (Dumbacher et al. 1992). Pitohui toxin,
known as homobatrachotoxin (homoBTX), is a
member of a well-known family of steroidal al-
kaloids that depolarize nerve and muscle mem-
branes by binding and activating voltage-de-
pendent sodium channels (Albuquerque et al.
1971). In some cases, concentrations of toxin
are sufficiently high that merely handling an
individual Hooded Pitohui (Pitohui dichrous)
can irritate buccal membranes and can cause
sneezing and burning, watery eyes (Salvadori
1881, Majnep and Bulmer 1977, Dumbacher et
al. 1992). Anthropological evidence suggests
that the toxin defends pitohuis from human
hunters (Majnep and Bulmer 1977; Kocher-
Schmid 1991, 1993), and other workers have
speculated that it also defends pitohuis against
natural predators (Diamond 1992) and arthro-
pod ectoparasites (Mouritsen and Madsen
1994, Poulsen 1994). Nevertheless, no studies
have directly investigated if the enemies of pi-
tohuis are deterred by homoBTX or how
homoBTX deters them.
Arthropod ectoparasites are natural enemies
of pitohuis and potential targets for pitohui de-
fensive chemicals. HomoBTX has been shown
to affect a wide range of vertebrates and inver-
tebrates (Albuquerque et al. 1971, Daly and
Present address: Molecular Genetics Laboratory,
National Zoological Park, Smithsonian Institution,
3001 Connecticut Avenue NW, Washington, D.C.
20008, USA. E-mail: jdumbacher@nzp. si.edu
Spande 1986, Dwivedy 1988). With the notable
exceptions of pitohuis and Phyllobates frogs,
nearly every animal that contains voltage-de-
pendent sodium channels is poisoned by ba-
trachotoxins, including distantly related ar-
thropods. Also, bird lice can influence host fit-
ness in several ways. Lice can affect the ener-
getics and survival of hosts (Clayton 1990,
Booth et al. 1993, Brown et al. 1995), reduce egg
numbers and hatching rates (Derylo 1974,
DeVaney 1976), reduce mating success (Ham-
ilton and Zuk 1982, Clayton 1990, Loye and
Zuk 1991, Clayton and Tompkins 1995), and
transmit pathogens (Marshall 1981, Clayton
1990). Therefore, defense against lice might be
under selection. Finally, a high proportion of a
pitohui's total toxin is concentrated in the skin
and feathers. Because lice live and feed on
feathers, skin, and subdermal blood supplies,
pitohui toxins could constitute a formidable
barrier to these ectoparasites.
HomoBTXs, and toxins in general, could de-
fend birds against lice through several alter-
native mechanisms. Toxins could (1) reduce
louse fecundity, (2) reduce louse survival, (3)
reduce the influence of lice on host fitness (e.g.
by delaying maturation, lengthening the life cy-
cle, or suppressing appetite), and (4) favorably
effect louse transmission rates by reducing im-
migration or inducing emigration. Here, I re-
port experimental studies that examine wheth-
er feather lice exhibit an active choice against
naturally toxic pitohui feathers and examine
whether the presence of natural levels of
TABLE 1. Sources and identification of chewing lice used in petri dish experiments.
[Auk, Vol. 116
Avian host species Parasite identification No. parasites
Ailuroedus buccoides
Alisterus chloropterus
Chalcophaps indica
Chalcophaps stephani
Chlamydera cerviniventris
Colluricincla megarhyncha
Cuculus saturatus
Gallicolumba jobiensis
Halcyon torotoro
Macropygia amboinensis
Melilestesmegarhynchus
Pitohui cristatus
Pitohuiferrugineus
Ptilinopusmagnificus
Ptilinopus pulchellus
Ptilinopus superbus
Tanysiptera danae
Brueelia pallida (Piaget, 1880)
Neopsittaconirmus circumfasciatus (Piaget, 1880)
Columbicola guimaraesi Tendeiro, 1965
Coloceras piriformis (Tendeiro, 1969)
Coloceras indicum Tendeiro, 1973
Columbicola sp.
Coloceras stephanii (Tendeiro, 1987)
Coloceras sp.
Myrsidea sp.
Philopterus sp.
Brueelia sp.
Cuculicola latirostris (Burmeister, 1838)
Columbicola exilicornis (Piaget, 1880)
Alcedoecus sp.
Columbicola sp.
Coloceras doreyanus (Eichler, 1950)
Brueelia sp.
Myrsidea sp.
Myrsidea sp. or Philopterus sp.
Columbicola harrisoni Tendeiro, 1965
Auricotes obscurus Keler, 1939
Hohorstiella sp.
Columbicola emersoni Tendeiro, 1960
Columbicola emersoni Tendeiro, 1960
Auricotes pazmartinae Tendeiro, 1976
Myrsidea sp.
1
48
6O
74
5
55
36
2O
7
1
6
1
4O
1
3
18
1
1
7
23
5
1
1
1
5
1
homoBTX affects the captive life span of these
lice.
Because toxin levels vary across pitohui spe-
cies, feathers from different pitohuis provide
naturally high and low toxicity treatments, and
outgroups provide nontoxic control feathers.
Individuals from five pitohui species are
known to contain some level of homoBTX
(Dumbacher 1997), with P. dichrous containing
the highest concentrations. In some popula-
tions, P. dichrous feathers contain more than 50
ixg of homoBTX per g of tissue, which is more
than 15 times the concentration originally re-
ported. Rusty Pitohui (P. ferrugineus) feathers
have much lower levels, and Crested Pitohui (P.
cristatus) feathers have nearly undetectable lev-
els of toxin.
METHODS
Studies were conducted at the Biological Research
Station, Varirata National Park (927'S, 147 21 'E; 840
m elevation), a 400-ha reserve on the Sogeri escarp-
ment approximately 40 km east of Port Moresby,
southeastern Papua New Guinea. Birds were trapped
in mist nets, measured (wing, tarsus, head and bill
length, and body mass), banded, visually inspected
for parasite loads, and released.
Lice were removed from host birds using fumi-
gation jars described by Bear (1995) and equipped so
industrial-grade CO2 could be pumped constantly
into the jar. Feathers were blown and ruffled to de-
tach anesthetized lice. The lice revived within 15-30
s of exposure to normal air and then were collected
in petri dishes where they were held until they could
be placed into experimental arenas, usually within
the hour.
In the field, lice from each individual host were
classified into "types" based on body plan and body
size. A type was defined as a group of morphologi-
cally similar lice taken from the same host. These
louse types were later identified, and they generally
corresponded to a particular species and age class
(adult or immature) within that species. It was likely
that each type within a particular host shared some
degree of genetic and/or environmental similarity
and thus, louse type provided a natural randomized
block for statistical analyses. Table 1 lists all of the
avian hosts that provided experimental lice and the
identification of these lice to genus or species.
Experiments were performed in plastic petri dish-
es that contained one or two feathers and one louse.
Dishes were kept at 18 to 22C and ambient humidity
(>45%) in a darkened room. In general, lice had dif-
ficulty walking across the dishes, which prevented
them from escaping. In dishes with more than one
feather, the second feather was placed above the first,
allowing lice to move freely from feather to feather
and thereby choose from which feather to feed or
rest.
All feathers were clean contour feathers in good
condition taken from the dorsum just behind the
wings. All non-pitohui feathers were presumed to be
nontoxic. After returning from the field, toxin con-
centrations in pitohui feathers were measured in the
Laboratory of Bio-organic Chemistry at the National
Institutes of Health using radio-ligand binding as-
says. Pitohui dichrous feathers used in this study con-
tained an average of 39 p,g of homoBTX per gram of
tissue, P. ferrugineus feathers contained an average of
3.5 g of homoBTX per gram of tissue, whereas P.
cristatus feathers contained less than 3 g homoBTX
per gram of tissue. Feathers collected from a variety
of non-pitohui species were used as nontoxic con-
trols.
Two types of experiments were conducted. The
first set of experiments, called choice experiments,
tested whether lice showed a preference against toxic
pitohui feathers when given a choice of two feathers
on which to feed and find shelter. The second set of
experiments, called life-span experiments, tested
whether pitohui toxins affected the life span of cap-
tive lice.
Choice experiments.--In the choice experiments,
feathers from two bird species were placed into petri
dishes, one above the other. Each petri dish con-
tained either one pitohui feather and one non-pito-
hui feather, or one P. dichrous feather and one less-
toxic pitohui feather (P. cristatus), matched for size
and general shape. Nontoxic control feathers were
used from six species: Accipiter poliocephalus (3 trials),
Ailuroedus buccoides (25), Chlamydera cerviniventris
(8), Colluricincla megarhyncha (49), Dicrurus hottentot-
tus (5), and Meliphaga analoga (15). After a feather was
used in an experiment, it was stored in a sealed plas-
tic bag. Because only a limited number of feathers
was available, some P. dichrous feathers were used in
a second experiment. Of the 105 trials of P. dichrous
feathers versus non-pitohui feathers, 23 (22%) incor-
porated previously used pitohui feathers. Reused
feathers were always placed in fresh petri dishes and
paired with a random unused feather from another
species.
For the louse to choose between feathers, the de-
sign required that one feather had to be placed on
top of the other and that each louse had to be placed
on a feather to begin the experiment. Because lice
may show an overall tendency not to move, or may
prefer the bottom feather (possibly due to negative
phototaxis; Marshall 1981), combinations of treat-
ment effects (which feather the louse was placed on
and which feather was on top) were distributed
evenly across petri dishes. For each petri dish, feath-
ers were randomly chosen from the two species be-
ing compared. Lice were randomly distributed to pe-
tri dishes and placed on the feather designated by
treatment design. Feathers were arranged one above
the other such that lice had easy access to both feath-
ers.
The trial began and the time was recorded when
the louse was placed on one of the two feathers. Ev-
ery 60 to 90 min between 0600 to 2400 Australian
EST, I recorded whether the louse was alive and
which feather it was on. If a louse was found alive on
the dish but not on a feather, it was returned to the
feather on which it had originally been placed. Each
louse was monitored until it died. All lice from these
experiments were preserved and stored at the Bishop
Museum in Honolulu, Hawaii.
An experiment was completed when the louse was
found dead in the experimental dish. All observa-
tions were tallied and a choice was recorded for the
feather on which the louse was most frequently ob-
served. In the event of a tie or if the louse was found
dead in the first observation period, the dish was ex-
cluded from subsequent analysis. Choices were tab-
ulated in contingency tables and blocked for the two
design effects: (1) which feather the louse was placed
on, and (2) which feather was on top. Choice exper-
iments were conducted during November and De-
cember 1995.
Life-span experiments.--Only feathers from P. di-
chrous, P. ferrugineus, and Colluricincla megarhyncha
were used. Colluricincla, the putative sister genus to
Pitohui, was chosen as a control to maximize the
structural similarity between Pitohui and control
feathers. The life-span experiments used the same
protocols as the choice experiments. There were
three treatments (1) feathers of P. dichrous and C. me-
garhyncha, (2) feathers of P. ferrugineus and C. mega-
rhyncha, and (3) a feather of C. megarhyncha alone.
Lice in treatment 1 were therefore exposed to high
natural levels of homoBTX, those in treatment 2 to
low natural levels of homoBTX, and those in treat-
ment 3 acted as controls that were not exposed to
homoBTX. Data were analyzed using analysis of var-
iance with life span as the dependent variable and
treatment as the independent variable, blocked by
louse type. Life-span experiments were conducted
February and March 1996.
Table 2 shows the proportions of the three most
common louse types used in each experiment. The
proportion of different louse genera used varied be-
tween experiments.
RESULTS
Effects of toxicity on feather choice.--I per-
formed 225 choice trials. Eleven trials ended in
ties and were excluded from subsequent anal-
yses. Lice showed a statistically significant
preference for the bottom feather (G-test with
Williams' correction, G = 15.52, df = 1, P <
0.01). Data were subsequently split into two
TABLE 2. Total number and proportion of louse
genera used in choice and life-span experiments.
Genus Total no. used % of total
Choice experiments (214 lice total)
Coloceras 116 54.2
Columbicola 79 36.9
Myrsidea 8 3.7
Other 11 5.1
Life-span experiments (208 lice total)
Columbicola 103 49.5
Neopsittacornirmus 48 23.1
Coloceras 35 16.8
Other 22 10.6
blocks: petri dishes in which the louse was
placed on the top feather and dishes in which
the louse was placed on the bottom feather
Within each block, data were compiled into 2 x
2 contingency tables tallying the starting feath-
er (toxic or nontoxic) versus the choice (stay on
starting feather or move), as shown in Table 3.
The two blocks were analyzed jointly using the
Mantel-Haenszel one-way X 2 statistic for block-
ing tables with one degree of freedom (Mantel
and Haenszel 1959, Mantel 1963).
Four different treatment combinations were
tested (Table 4). Lice avoided P. dichrous feath-
ers in favor of nontoxic control feathers (Man-
tel-Haenszel statistic = 10.17, df = 1, n = 105
trials, P < 0.0015; Table 4). Even excluding tri-
als with previously used P. dichrous feathers,
lice avoided P. dichrous feathers in favor of non-
toxic feathers (Mantel-Haenszel statistic = 5.84,
df = 1, n = 82 trials, P < 0.015), although the
level of statistical significance dropped in ac-
cordance with losing 22% of the experimental
sample.
Effects of toxicity on louse life span.--Life span
in captivity varied among different types of lice
(F = 3.17, df = 28 and 121, P < 0.0001). To avoid
confounding effects of treatment with effects of
louse type, I used only louse types that were ex-
TABLE 3. Contingency table showing the marginal
frequency distribution of all choice experiment tri-
als, Lice are more likely to move off of a more toxic
feather than a less toxic feather.
No. of lice
No. of lice moving to
staying on other
Feather on which original feather
parasite was placed feather or to dish
More-toxic feather 24 82
Less-toxic feather 46 62
posed to all three treatments and performed
ANOVA using Type III sums of squares (Shaw
and Mitchell-Olds 1993). Life-span data for 29
different louse types were analyzed for a total
of 208 trials. Feather treatment (i.e. toxicity) sig-
nificantly affected the life span of captive lice
(F = 5.30, df = 2 and 56, P = 0.012).
Estimates of mean life span for each treat-
ment are presented in Table 5. Lice exposed to
feathers of P. dichrous or P. ferrugineus died sig-
nificantly earlier than those living on feathers
of C. megarhyncha (a posteriori Bonferroni t-tests,
c = 0.05). Life span did not differ significantly
between lice exposed to feathers of P. dichrous
versus P. ferrugineus (P > 0.05).
DISCUSSION
In the choice experiments, lice showed a sta-
tistically significant preference against feeding
and resting on P. dichrous feathers. The ecolog-
ical significance of this choice is unclear be-
cause lice rarely have an opportunity to move
between hosts except during host mating and
nesting periods. For many bird species, mating
occurs briefly and lice have little opportunity
to discriminate between hosts on the basis of
toxicity. Recent evidence suggests that the most
toxic pitohui species, P. dichrous, breeds coop-
eratively (Legge and Heinsohn 1996), so during
TABLE 4. Results of choice experiments. Four different treatment combinations were tested. Sample sizes
for each test are given, contingency tables were blocked for effects of top and bottom feathers, and the
probability of Mantel-Haenszel test statistics are presented.
Toxic feather Less-toxic feather
(toxicity) (toxicity) n P
Pitohui dichrous (high) Nontoxic control 105 <0.001
Pitohui dichrous (high) Pitohui cristatus (low) 36 0.373
Pitohuiferrugineus (low) Colluricincla megarhyncha (nontoxic) 23 0.771
Pitohui cristatus (low) Colluricincla megarhyncha (nontoxic) 50 0.354
TABLE 5. Mean life span of lice in presence of feath-
ers of different toxicity.
Mean life
Most toxic feather span
in petri dish (h) n
Pitohui dichrous 35.0 74
Pitohui ferrugineus 41.4 67
Colluricincla megarhyncha 81.5 67
nesting, lice may have a choice of multiple
adult and nestling hosts. Therefore, if lice can
move to less-toxic individuals in the nest en-
vironment, birds without toxins may bear an
unusually high lice load, and selection for an-
tiparasite toxins could occur.
During nonbreeding seasons of avian hosts,
lice may have little or no opportunity to move
between hosts. Lice may still be repelled by
homoBTX and drop off the host because many
lice chose the dish over the toxic feather. A sec-
ond possibility is that lice may be transmitted
via phoresis, that is, attached to another more-
mobile parasite such as a hippoboscid fly. Al-
though phoresis is believed to be uncommon
(Marshall 1981), it may facilitate transmission
away from toxic hosts because hippoboscid
flies were common on pitohuis (Dumbacher
1997). Alternatively, lice may migrate to areas
of the bird's body that contain lower concentra-
tions of toxin. If lice are repelled from toxic ar-
eas on an individual host, selection may favor
a toxin distribution that protects regions of the
body that are the most likely to be parasitized,
or that pose the highest threat to host fitness.
HomoBTX profoundly increased louse mor-
tality in the life-span experiments. Lice placed
in dishes with P. dichrous feathers died sooner
than those in dishes with C. megarhyncha feath-
ers, which have undetectable levels of toxin.
The life span of lice exposed to P. ferrugineus
feathers decreased significantly compared with
those exposed to C. megarhyncha feathers, even
though toxin levels in P. ferrugineus feathers are
about 10 times lower than those in P. dichrous
feathers. Thus, toxin concentrations in P. ferru-
gineus and P. cristatus may be too low to repel
lice but still may increase louse mortality.
Reducing the life span of lice can have three
profound consequences for host-parasite inter-
actions. First, any given louse will feed for a re-
duced period of time, reducing its individual
effect on its host. Second, on average, the entire
population of lice will be smaller at any given
time. Smaller populations may irritate the host
less, or may be less visible to a host's potential
mates. Third, if the life span of lice is reduced
enough, the probability of survival to mating
decreases, and subsequent generations of lice
will be reduced in number
In addition, lice that lived the longest ap-
peared to be feeding on feathers of C. mega-
rhyncha. Black powder, assumed to be fecal pel-
lets or discarded feather bits, accumulated on
the petri dishes beneath C. megarhyncha feath-
ers. After 4 to 5 days, these lice had damaged
a noticeable fraction of the feather. In dishes
with P. dichrous feathers, however, lice rarely
showed evidence of eating either of the feath-
ers. In dishes with P. dichrous feathers, lice also
became immobile and inactive. This may allow
pitohuis to remove lice more easily during
preening or even while flying. Given that many
lice were sluggish and did not feed on pitohui
feathers, pitohui toxin may also lower feeding
rates and thus reduce each louse's effect. These
hypotheses deserve future testing.
Life span varied significantly among louse
types (F = 3.17, df = 28 and 121, P < 0.0001).
For the extreme examples, Brueelia lived an av-
erage 145 h in captivity, whereas Coloceras lived
an average of 25 h. This difference may be due
to many attributes of the different louse types,
including overall differences in life span, feed-
ing needs, previous condition, or the response
to stresses of captivity. Seven lice collected
from a single Pitohui ferrugineus host lived on
average 194 h, which is the longest average cap-
tive life span of any louse type in these exper-
iments. This may be due to homoBTX insensi-
tivity because these lice have coevolved with
toxic pitohuis. However, even these lice showed
a marked difference in life span across treat-
ments; those on P. dichrous feathers lived an av-
erage of 36.6 h (n = 3), those on P. ferrugineus
feathers lived an average of 129.8 h (n = 2), and
those on C. megarhyncha feathers lived an av-
erage of 417 h (n = 2). Also, the ANOVA re-
vealed a significant interaction of treatment by
louse type (F = 1.63, df = 56 and 121, P =
0.013), which suggests that different types of
lice react differently to the effects of homoBTX.
For example, Neopsittaconirmus circumfasciatus
showed no overall difference in life span due to
feather toxicity, whereas Brueelia showed pro-
found differences.
Although I collected few lice from pitohuis
for this study, infestation rates in pitohuis do
not appear to differ significantly from those of
other muscicapids (Dumbacher 1997, R. Elbel
pers. comm.).
Three caveats should be mentioned concern-
ing my experiments. First, the experimental
dishes were cooler, drier, darker, and more sed-
entary than a live bird's plumage. The stress of
captivity may intensify effects of pitohui toxins
on lice. Second, the experimental dishes may
expose lice to unnaturally low concentrations
of toxin. In the dishes, lice have a choice of two
feathers, one of which is nontoxic. Also, be-
cause feathers contain much lower concentra-
tions of toxin than skin (Dumbacher et al.
1992), exposure to feathers alone may under-
estimate the effect of natural levels of homo-
BTX on lice. Third, many experimental lice
were collected from bird species distantly re-
lated to pitohuis. Although pitohui toxin pro-
foundly affected these lice, the toxin may have
different effects on lice that coevolved with pi-
tohuis because parasites often evolve resistance
to host defenses. However, pitohui toxins have
profound effects on many species of lice, sug-
gesting that these toxins had profound effects
on pitohui lice during the evolution of toxicity
in pitohuis.
It has been suggested that chewing lice have
little or no influence on the fitness of their avian
hosts (Rothschild and Clay 1952, Ash 1960,
Marshall 1981), although recent studies sug-
gest otherwise. Lice can reduce egg number
and hatching success in chickens (Derylo 1974,
DeVaney 1976), and studies of mate choice in
Rock Doves (Columba livia) have shown that fe-
males discriminate against males with high
louse loads (Clayton 1990). In addition, lice can
damage plumage to the extent that thermal
conductance is increased, which would in-
crease the metabolic costs of temperature reg-
ulation (Booth et al. 1993). Even in low num-
bers, lice can transmit diseases that profoundly
affect the fitness of their avian hosts (Clayton
1990).
Pitohui toxin may also affect other arthropod
ectoparasites. Pitohui toxin attacks sodium
channels composed of highly conserved pro-
teins. These sodium channels are found in all
other arthropod ectoparasites including feath-
er mites, sucking mites, hippoboscid flies, soft
and hard ticks, and ephemeral ectoparasites
such as chiggers, mosquitoes, and leeches.
Many of these ectoparasites are believed to be
more detrimental to host fitness than are feath-
er lice. Additional studies of these other ecto-
parasites are needed.
This study clearly demonstrates the mecha-
nisms by which homobatrachotoxin can defend
wild pitohuis against ectoparasites. However,
because homoBTX affects predators and per-
haps other parasites as well as lice, it is difficult
to assess the relative role of louse defense in the
evolution and maintenance of pitohui toxins.
Naturally occurring levels of homoBTX affect
New Guinea predators such as green tree py-
thons (Chondropython viridis) and brown tree
snakes (Boiga irregularis) and are known to de-
ter human hunters (Majnep and Bulmer 1977,
Kocher-Schmid 1991). The bright orange-and-
black plumage pattern of the two most toxic pi-
tohuis, P. dichrous and P. kirhocephalus, probably
serves as an aposematic signal for visual pred-
ators such as hawks and thus would not affect
lice. Consequently, homobatrachotoxin repre-
sents a single evolutionary innovation that may
simultaneously influence a broad spectrum of
pitohui enemies.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I thank the Papua New Guinea Department of En-
vironment and Conservation and the PNG Research
and Conservation Foundation for providing visa as-
sistance and permission to conduct this study, and
the personnel at Varirata National Park for logistical
support, especially P. Ainie and Bisikau Iova. I also
thank Bulisa A. Iova for helping capture birds and
lice, and S. O'Steen and R. M. Gaylord for assisting
with experimental design and field work. S. Arnold,
J. Bergelson, D. Clayton, R. Elbel, M. Kreitman, R.
Page, S. Pruett-Jones, R. Price, and M. Wade provided
insightful comments on the manuscript. Chemical
analyses were directed by J. W. Daly and supported
and carried out in the National Institutes of Health
Laboratory of Bio-organic Chemistry. R. Price pro-
vided invaluable assistance in identifying lice to ge-
nus or species; however, I accept responsibility for
any misidentifications. Funding for field work was
provided by the University of Chicago Hinds Fund
and National Geographic Society Grant 5082-93. The
author was supported by a William Rainey Harper
Fellowship and GAANN Ecology Fellowship from
the University of Chicago.
LITERATURE CITED
ALBUQUERQUE, E. X., J. W. DAL3/4, AND B. WITKOP.
1971. Batrachotoxin: Chemistry and pharmacol-
ogy. Science 172:995-1002.
AsH, J. S. 1960.,A study of the Mallophaga of birds
with particular reference to their ecology. Ibis
102:93-110.
BEAR, g. 1995. An improved method for collecting
bird ectoparasites. Journal of Field Ornithology
66:212-214.
BOOTH, D. T., D. H. CLAYTON, ANDB. A. BLOCK. 1993.
Experimental demonstration of the energetic
cost of parasitism in free-ranging hosts. Pro-
ceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B
253:125-129.
BROWN, C. R., M. B. BROWN, AND B. RANNALA. 1995.
Ectoparasites reduce long-term survival of their
avian host. Proceedings of the Royal Society of
London Series B 262:313-319.
CLAYTON, D. H. 1990. Mate choice in experimentally
parasitized Rock Doves: Lousy males lose.
American Zoologist 30:251-262.
CLAYTON, D. H., AND D. M. TOMPKINS. 1995. Corn-
parative effects of mites and lice on the repro-
ductive success of Rock Doves (Columba livia).
Parasitology 110:195-206.
DALY, J. W., AND t. F. SPANDE. 1986. Amphibian al-
kaloids: Chemistry, pharmacology, and biology.
Pages 1-274 in Alkaloids: Chemical and biolog-
ical perspectives (S. W. Pelletier, Ed.). John Wiley
and Sons, New York.
DERYLO, A. 1974. Studies on the economic harmful-
ness of the Mallophaga. II. Influence of lice in-
festation on egg laying and hatching of hens.
Medycyna Weterynaryjna 30:406-410 [In Pol-
ish].
DEVANEY, J. g. 1976. Effects of the chicken body
louse, Menacanthus stramineus, on caged layers.
Poultry Science 55:430-435.
DIAMOND, J. M. 1992. Rubbish birds are poisonous.
Nature 360:19-20.
DUMBACHER, J.P. 1997. The ecology and evolution of
chemical defense in the avian genus Pitohui.
Ph.D. dissertation, University of Chicago, Chi-
cago.
DUMBACHER, J. ?., B. M. BEEHLER, t. E SPANDE, H. M.
GARRAFFO, AND J. W. DALY. 1992. Homobatrach-
otoxin in the genus Pitohui: Chemical defense in
birds? Science 258:799-801.
DWIVEDY, A. K. 1988. Alkaloid neurotoxins-depen-
dent sodium transport in insect synaptic nerve-
ending particles. Comparative Biochemistry and
Physiology 91C:349-354.
HAMILTON, W. D., AND M. ZUK. 1982. Heritable true
fitness and bright birds: A role for parasites? Sci-
ence 218:384-387.
KOCHER-SCHMIO, C. 1991. Of people and plants: A
botanical ethnography of Nokopo Village, Ma-
dang and Morobe Provinces, Papua New Guin-
ea. Ethnologisches Seminar der Universitit und
Museum fiir V/51kerkunde, in Kommission bei
Wepf und Co., Basel, Switzerland.
KOCHER-SCHMID, C. 1993. Birds of Nokopo. Muruk 6:
1-15.
LEGGE, S., AND R. HEINSOHN. 1996. Cooperative
breeding in Hooded Pitohuis Pitohui dichrous.
Emu 96:139-140.
LOYE, J. E., AND M. ZUK. 1991. Bird-parasite inter-
actions: Ecology, evolution, and behaviour. Ox-
ford University Press, Oxford.
MAJNEP, I. S., AND R. BULMER. 1977. Birds of my Ka-
lam Country. Aukland University Press, Auk-
land, New Zealand.
MANTEL, N. 1963. Chi-square tests with one degree
of freedom: Extensions of the Mantel-Haenszel
procedure. American Statistical Association
Journal 58:690-700.
MANTEL, IN[., AND W. HAENSZEL. 1959. Statistical as-
pects of the analysis of data from retrospective
studies of disease. Journal of the National Cancer
Institute 22:719-748.
MARSHALL, g. G. 1981. The ecology of ectoparasitic
insects. Academic Press, London.
MOURITSEN, K. N., AND J. MADSEN. 1994. Toxic birds:
Defence against parasites? Oikos 69:357-358.
POULSEN, B. O. 1994. Poison in Pitohui birds: Against
predators or ectoparasites? Ernu 94:128-129.
ROTHSCHILO, M., AND t. CLAY. 1952. Fleas, flukes,
and cuckoos: A study of bird parasites. Collins,
London.
SALVADORI, t. 1881. Ornitologia della Papuasia e del-
le Molucche. Socio Residente della R. Accadernia
delle Scienze di Torino, Parte Seconda.
SHAW, R. G., AND T. MITCHELL-OLDS. 1993. ANOVA
for unbalanced data: An overview. Ecology 74:
1638-1645.
Associate Editor: A. J. Baker