During the middle of the dry season (February-March), we performed low-altitude aerial strip-censuses to estimate densities of waterbirds in the Atlantic coastal wetlands of Nicaragua and Honduras (Miskito Coast and La Mosquitia, respectively), areas which are poorly known ornithologically. We found 12.9 and 5.5 waterbirds/km 2 in 294.6 and 281.5 km 2 surveyed in Nicaragua and Honduras, respectively. Great Egrets (Ardea alba) were most common and widespread, representing 53% (Nicaragua) and 46% (Honduras) of the sightings. Wood Storks (Mycteria americana) and Egretta herons were the next two most abundant groups. Breeding colonies of Wood Storks, Roseate Spoonbills (Ajaia ajaja), and Great Egrets were found in both areas, most nests containing eggs and small chicks. We document a previously unrecorded population of Jabiru Storks (Jabiru mycteria) breeding in both areas, with densities of 0.05 and 0.16 birds/km 2, respectively. The wetlands of both countries appear to support a large proportion of the breeding Jabirus in Central America and should be given high priority for conservation.
Department of WiLtlife Ecolog 3, and Conservation
P.O. Box 110430
University of Florida
Gainesville, Florida 32611-0430 USA
El Colegio de la b3/4ontera Sur
Aptdo. Postal 424 Chetumal
77000 Quintana Roo, Mexico
Project Lighthawk
P.O. Box 8163
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87504-8163 USA
Department of Pathobiolog O,
University of Florida
Gainesville, Florida 32611 USA
LA IMPORTANCIA DE LOS ANEGADOS COSTEROS DEL CARIBE DE NICARAGUA Y
HONDURAS PARA LAS POBLACIONES DE CENTRO AMIRICA DE AVES
VADEADORAS Y PARA JABIRU MYCTERIA
Sinopsis.--Llevamos a cabo censos a6reos de banda a poca altitud para estimar las densi-
dades de aves vadeadoras en los anegados de la costa del AtNntico de Nicaragua y de Hon-
Current address: The Aldo Leopold Shack Foundation, E-12919 Levee Road, Baraboo, scon-
sin 53913 USA.
duras (Costa Miskito y La Mosquita, respectivamente), /treas poco conocidas ornitol6gica-
mente, a mediados de la temporada seca (febrero a marzo). Hallamos 12.9 y 5.5 aves vadea-
doras/km 2 en los 294.6 km 2 y 281.5 Km 2examinados respectivamente. Las aves ms co-
munes y mejor distribuidas fueron Ardea alba, representando un 53% (Nicaragua) y un
46% (Honduras) de las observaciones. Las otras dos especies m/rs abundantes fueron Myc-
teria americana y Egretta thula. Se hallaron colonias de nidos de Mycteria americana, Ajaja
ajaja y Egretta thula en ambas/treas, la mayoria de los nidos con huevos y pichones. Docu-
mentamos una poblaci6n previamente ignorada de Jabiru mycteria, con densidades de 0.05
aves/km 2 y 0.16 aves/km reproduci6ndose en ambas/treas. Las zonas anegadas de ambos
paises parecen sostener una gran proporci6n de losJabiru mycteria anidando en la Am6rica
Central, y se deberia dar prioridad a su preservaci6n.
The wetlands of the Atlantic coastal regions of Honduras (La Mosqui-
tia) and Nicaragua (Miskito coast) are some of the most extensive in Cen-
tral America, but remain poorly known ornithologically (Fig. 1). The
coastal wetlands and some of the more common waterbirds are described
briefly in the IWRB Directory of Neotropical Wetlands (Scott and Car-
bonnel 1986), and Camacho (1983) suggested the possible importance
of the area forJabiru Storks. Otherwise, the avifauna of the area is known
in print from one early collection (Huber 1932), Monroe's (1968) survey
of eastern Honduras, and Howell's (1971) study of eastern Nicaragua. The
avifauna of the region may also be surmised from several reports from
southeastern Nicaragua (Richmond 1893, Sclater and Salvin 1867, Sclater
1873, Will 1991), and Costa Rica (Stiles and Skutch 1989).
In this paper, we report on densities of large waterbirds in these wet-
lands during the dry season, as determined through low-altitude aerial
surveys, and compare these densities to those obtained in studies of other
New World tropical and subtropical wetlands. We found that these rela-
tively unimpacted wetlands host high densities of ciconiiform birds and
are of regional importance for Jabiru Storks. We believe this effort is the
first quantitative survey of waterbirds in the La Mosquitia/Miskito Coast
ecosystem.
METHODS
We performed low-altitude strip-censuses of waterbirds in the Atlantic
coast wetlands of the Miskito Goast of Nicaragua (March 1992) and La
Mosquitia in Honduras (February 1994). We counted birds systematically
on both sides of a low-flying aircraft, using standard methodology for sur-
veys of wildlife in open-country savannas (Bancroft and Sawicki 1995,
Bjork and Powell 1994, Hoffman et al. 1990, Norton-Griffiths 1975). If the
altitude is known, and observers on both sides of the aircraft restrict their
counts to demarcated strips of ground on either side of the plane (outlined
with marks on the windows and struts), then the area in which animals have
been counted can be calculated (Norton-Griffiths 1975). Densities can
then be extrapolated to total population counts if the habitat is uniform
or if the counts can be stratified by habitat type. We chose not to do the
latter, since adequate vegetation maps were not available to us.
Flying or standing birds were counted only if they occurred within these
visually defined strips. Ground positions were obtained using a global po-
Punta Patuca
Honduras
0 20 40 km
Puarto Lempira
Cabo Gracias
a Dios
Nicaragua
Puerto Cabezas
Haulover
FIGURE 1. Map of coastal regions of northeastern Nicaragua and southeastern Honduras,
showing large towns and locations of strip-transect aerial surveys (dashed lines).
sitioning system with an accuracy <100 m. Bird species and numbers were
recorded onto paper forms by the observers, with positions called out
upon demand by a third observer. All participants communicated by head-
set. Data were recorded separately for each straight-line transect (Fig. 1);
length of each transect was calculated using the starting and ending po-
sitions of the transect.
We concentrated our surveys in areas of wetland that were not heavily
forested and that had standing surface water. We did not attempt to count
birds in the large open saline lagoons characteristic of the region, which
are generally >1 m in depth. Our search for wetlands by definition was
biased towards sparse mangrove swamps and wet prairies, and tended to
exclude hardwood forest, pine savannas, and gallery forest. While we feel
our transects covered representative wetland types with surface water at
the time of surveys, our study should not be construed as having sampled
wetland habitat types in proportion to their availabilities. Transects were
generally oriented east-west to make effects of sun glare equal on both
sides of the plane. The only exception to this rule were wetlands occur-
ring in thin strips immediately adjacent to beaches, where transects were
conducted parallel to the long axis of wetlands.
Snowy Egrets (Egretta thula) and immature Little Blue Herons (Egretta
caerulea) are both white-plumaged and difficult to distinguish at the alti-
tudes we used. We therefore categorized both as "small white herons,"
(Bancroft and Sawicki 1995, Hoffman et al. 1990). Similarly, adult Little
Blue Herons and Tricolored Herons (Egretta tricolor) are difficult to dis-
tinguish when viewed from above, and were both categorized as "small
dark herons."
M.G.S. and P.C.F. were observers on survey flights in the Miskito Coast
wetlands of Nicaragua between the Rio Coco and Wounta on 3, 4, 8, and
9 Mar. 1992. Survey flights were flown at 108 m altitude and 166 km/h
groundspeed in a Cessna 206, counting birds in strips of approximately
271 m on either side of the plane.
P.C.F. and J.S.C. were observers on survey flights in Honduras between
15 and 19 Feb. 1994, between the Rio Coco on the south and Cabo Ca-
maron in the north, in a centerline-thrust twin-engined Cessna 137 Sky-
master at 61 m altitude and 166 km/h groundspeed. Transects totalled
697 km; using a calculated strip width of 206 m, we estimated that birds
were counted within a total area of 282 km ' in the Honduran wetlands.
RESULTS
Survey. results.--We found 3786 waterbirds in the 295 kin" surveyed in
Nicaragua, and 1547 in the 282 kin" surveyed in Honduras, yielding over-
all densities of 12.9 and 5.5 birds/km e, respectively (Table 1). In both
surveys, the most common species was the Great Egret, accounting for
53% of the total in Nicaragua, and 46% of the total in Honduras. In Nica-
ragua, Wood Storks were second in abundance (17% of birds seen), small
dark herons comprised 10%, and small white herons 7%. In Honduras,
small white herons (largely Snowy Egrets) comprised nearly 15% of the
total. The numbers of small dark herons are likely to be under-estimated
due to poor detectability of these dark birds. White Ibises (Eudocimus al-
bus), a dominant species in southeastern United States and Venezuelan
surveys, were rarely seen in Nicaragua and Honduras. Roseate Spoonbills
were seen in small numbers during both surveys.
Densities in Nicaragua were almost twice those of Honduras. Our den-
sities from the two countries were in the middle of the range of estimates
for central Florida (2.3-164.0 birds/km", Frederick and McGehee 1994),
and the central (6.6-106.89 birds/km", Bancroft and Sawicki 1995) and
coastal (17.5-24 birds/km", Bjork and Powell 1993) Everglades. In all
TABLE 1. Summary of waterbird surveys in coastal Honduras and Nicaragua during the dry
season.
Honduras Nicaragua
Number Number Proportion Number Number Proportion
Species seen per km"of total seen per km ' of total
Anhinga anhinga 2 0.01 0.001 0 0 0
Anas discors 20 0.07 0 0 0 0
Cairina moschata 28 0.10 0.018 130 0.44 0.034
Dendrocygna spp. 275 0.98 0.178 69 0.23 0.018
Unidentified ducks 4 0.01 0.003 0 0 0
Small white herons 226 0.80 0.146 273 0.93 0.072
Ardea herodias 29 0.10 0.019 126 0.43 0.033
Ardea alba 712 2.53 0.460 2011 6.83 0.531
Small dark herons 62 0.22 0.040 372 1.26 0.098
Ajaia ajaja 24 0.09 0.016 47 0.16 0.012
Eudocimus albus 63 0.22 0.040 59 0.20 0.016
Jabiru mycteria 13 0.05 0.008 47 0.16 0.012
Mycteria americana 89 0.32 0.058 652 2.21 0.172
Total, all species 1547 5.50 1.00 3786 12.85 1.00
cases, these densities have been standardized for the amount of wetted
marsh area surveyed (areas without standing surface water excluded).
Perhaps the most striking finding was the number of Jabiru Storks that
we counted (47 in Nicaragua, 13 in Honduras), yielding estimated densi-
ties of 0.16 and 0.05/km 2, respectively. If Jabirus seen just outside the
transects are included, we saw a total of 74 in 545 km of flying in Nicara-
gua, and 24 in 697 km of flying in Honduras. Jabirus were typically soli-
tary and in pairs, though a single flock of four was seen.
Breeding activity.wOur surveys covered only a small fraction of the po-
tential wetland nesting sites in each study area. In Honduras, we located
two breeding aggregations of long-legged wading birds on islands within
or on the edges of Laguna Kohunta and a very small lagoon northwest of
Laguna Apalca. At the Laguna Kohunta colony we counted 165 Wood
Stork nests with eggs or chicks, and 17-20 Roseate Spoonbill nests, prob-
ably with eggs. At the much larger Apalca Northwest colony, we counted
1520 Wood Stork nests with eggs or chicks, 155 Roseate Spoonbill nests,
and approximately 150 Great Egret nests. Snowy Egrets may also have
been nesting at this latter colony, but we were unable to confirm this with-
out ground visits. Birds in these colonies appeared to be in incubation
and early chick rearing activities, which would place dates of initiation in
late December (Wood Storks) to mid-January (Roseate Spoonbills).
During the Nicaraguan surveys in 1992, we also found small colonies
of Wood Storks (160 pairs) and Roseate Spoonbills (24 pairs). The Wood
Stork nests contained small young and eggs, and the Roseate Spoonbills
appeared to be incubating eggs. Timing of nesting for both these species
in Honduras and Nicaragua appears quite similar to that observed in
Texas, Florida, and the Yucatan (Mien 1942, Bjork and Powell 1994, Cor-
rea 1992, Lopez Ornat and Ramo 1992).
In Nicaragua, we found four Jabiru nests, two of which were inside our
transects. Two additional Jabiru nests were found incidentally during 6 h
of manatee survey flights, for a total of six nests found in the area. Of the
six Jabiru nests we found, one had large young, three had medium sized
young, one was apparently incubating, and one was standing on a com-
plete nest platform with no eggs or young in the nest.
In Honduras, we found a total of four Jabiru Stork nests (three with
chicks 1-2-mo old, one without eggs or chicks), two of which fell within
our survey strips, and two of which were seen while in transit between
survey transects and Puerto Lempira.
DISCUSSION
The density of waterbirds in Honduras was about half that estimated in
Nicaragua (Table 1). This was true for all of the waterbird species indi-
vidually, with exceptions only for whistling ducks (Dendrocygna spp.),
Blue-winged Teal (Arias discors), White Ibises, and small white herons.
Densities of Jabiru Storks in Honduras were less than 33% those in Nica-
ragua, those of Wood Storks less than 15%, and those of Muscovy Ducks
(Cairina moschata) less than 25%.
Differences in densities were unlikely to have been due to differing
methodologies, because the survey flights in both locations were per-
formed at similar altitudes, using the same techniques for estimating strip
widths, orienting flight transects, counting, recording, and analysis. One
of the two observers in Honduras (PCF) was also an observer in the Nica-
raguan surveys. The variety of habitat and water depths traversed, and
wide geographical distribution of transects was quite similar in both sur-
vey efforts.
Nonetheless, it is not clear that the survey results in the two areas are
due to inherently different carrying capacities of the two landscapes. The
surveys were performed in different years with quite different weather pat-
terns, and even at slightly different times of year (late February in Hon-
duras, early March in Nicaragua). Interviews with residents in Nicaragua
in 1992 suggested that weather and surface water conditions were normal
for that time of year, with the low rainfall typical of the dry season. Simi-
lar interviews in Honduras in 1994 were just the opposite. Fishermen, lo-
cal pilots, church workers, and other residents seemed to agree that the
winter of 1994 had been abnormally wet, and that a typical dry season
had not become established. Since waterbird densities in other large sub-
tropical and tropical wetland regions in the Yucatan (Lopez Ornat and
Ramo 1992), and the Everglades (Bancroft and Sawicki 1995, Hoffman et
al. 1990) are usually much lower during wet conditions, it seems likely
that weather pattern alone could explain the apparent differences
between Nicaraguan and Honduran surveys.
We also saw more Blue-winged Teal in the Honduran surveys than were
counted in Nicaragua. This is likely due to sampling error, because Blue-
winged Teal are usually encountered in flocks and the total number seen
in Honduras was relatively small (20 individuals). In Nicaragua, we in fact
did see several large flocks of teal in the lagoons, but did not count them
because they did not fall within the survey strips.
This survey confirms the general species abundance pattern found in
wetlands throughout Central America, with geographic and numeric
dominance by Great Egrets and other herons, and much smaller num-
bers of Wood Storks, White Ibises, and other tactile feeders (Correa 1992,
Frederick and Spalding 1992, Ogden et al. 1988). This pattern is distinct
from that found in the wetlands of both the southeastern United States
and the northeastern coast and interior wet plains of South America,
where ibises tend to dominate the wading bird biomass (Bancroft and
Sawicki 1995, Bildstein 1993, Kushlan and White 1977, Morales and Pa-
checo 1986, Spaans 1990).
This study confirms that Jabiru Storks breed in substantial numbers in
the study area, contra Monroe (1968). Cottea and Luthin (1988) found
0.06 Jabiru Storks/km 9 in the Usamacinta Delta wetlands of Mexico,
about half the density found in Nicaragua, and nearly the same den-
sity as Honduras. Villareal (1996) found between 0.44 and 4.8 indi-
viduals/km 9 in Mata Redondo Lagoon in Costa Rica between January
and April of 1993. Similarly, Brooks (1991, in Hancock et al. 1992)
reported 4.38 individuals/kin 9 in aggregations in the Chaco region of
Paraguay. Gonzalez (1993) and Thomas (1985) found 0.028 and 2.0
nesting pairs/km 9, respectively, in the Venezuelan Llanos. The den-
sities of adults we saw feeding on the marsh surface are suggestive of
0.03 and 0.08 pairs/kin 9. Thus densities of nesting pairs in the La
Mosquitia/Miskito Coast region may be similar to those in the Llanos of
Venezuela.
Correa and Luthin (1988) suggested that the Jabiru Stork population
of Central America may follow seasonal movements among Mexico,
Belize, and Guatemala. The very high concentrations found by Ogden et
al. (1988), Villareal (1996), and Cottea and Luthin (1988) suggest that
large seasonal influxes do occur in various parts of Central America.
Hancock et al. (1992) estimated the entire Central American population
of Jabirus to be no more than 250 individuals. The 98 individuals we saw
in our incomplete surveys suggests that the Atlantic coast wetlands of
Nicaragua and Honduras host a large portion of the Central American
population.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by Lighthawk, Inc. (Honduras and Nicaragua studies) and the
Caribbean Conservation Corporation (Nicaragua), with grants from the U.S. Agency for In-
ternational Development, the Liz Claiborne and Art Ortenberg Foundations, and the Mo-
riah Fund. Our work was supported logistically by the staff and resources of IRENA (New
name, MARENA, the Nicaraguan Ministry of Natural Resources) and MIKUPIA in Nicara-
gua, and by Lighthawk's La Mosquitia project and MOPAWI in Honduras. We thank B. Row-
ell for assistance with photos and data recording in Honduras. We are indebted to B. Stith
and L. Pearlstein for help with GIS applications associated with this project. This is Journal
Series R-05370 of the Florida Agricultural Experiment Station.
LITERATURE CITED
ALLEN, R.P. 1942. The Roseate Spoonbill. National Audubon Society, New York, New York.
BkNCROFT, G. T., XND R.J. S^cgI. 1995. The distribution and abundance of wading birds
relative to hydrologic patterns in the Water Conservation Areas of the Everglades. Final
report to the South Florida Water Management District. West Palm Beach, Florida.
BILDSTEIN, K. L. 1993. White Ibis, wetland wanderer. Smithsonian Institution Press, Wash-
ington, D.C.
BJORK, R. B., 2ND G. V. N. Pox&I.L. 1994. Relationships between hydrological conditions
and quality and quantity of foraging habitat for Roseate Spoonbills and other wading
birds in the C-111 basin. Everglades National Park, Homestead, Florida.
CXMCHO, M. G. 1983. Notes on aquatic birds of Nicaragua, Jabiru mycteria. Inst. Nicarag.
Rec. Nat. Ambient. 14 pp.
CORRF&, J. 1992. Status of aquatic birds in the coastal wetlands of the Yucatan peninsula.
M.Sc. thesis, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, England. 110 pp.
, AND C. S. LUTHIN. 1988. Proposal for the conservation of theJabiru Stork in South-
east Mexico. Pp. 607-615, in Memoria del Simposio sobre la Ecologia y Conservacion
del Delta de los Rios Usamacinta y Grijalva. Instituto Nacional de Investigacion sobre
Recursos Bioticos, Division Regional, Tabasco, Mexico.
GONZALEZ, J. A. 1993. Contribucion al estudio de la ecologia de las ciguenos (Fam. Cico-
niidae) en los Llanos de Venezuela. PhD dissertation, Universidad Complutense de
Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
FREDERICK, P. C., AND S. M. MCGEHEE. 1994. Wading bird use of wastewater wetlands in
central Florida, USA. Colonial Waterbirds 17:50-59.
, AND M. G. SPALDING. 1992. Factors affecting reproductive success of wading birds
(Ciconiformes) in the Everglades ecosystem. Pp. 569-691, in S. Davis and J. C. Ogden,
eds. Everglades: the Ecosystem and its Restoration. St. Lucie Press, Del Ray Beach,
Florida.
HANCOCK, J. A., J. A. KUSHLAN, AND M.P. IHL. 1992. Storks, Ibises, and Spoonbills of the
World. Academic Press, San Diego, California.
HOFFMAN, W., G. T. BANCROFT, AND R. j. s^wicKi. 1990. Wading bird populations and dis-
tributions in the Water Conservation Areas of the Everglades: 1985-1988. South Florida
Water Management District, West Palm Beach, Florida.
HOWELL, T. R. 1971. An ecological study of the birds of the lowland pine savanna and
adjacent rain forest in northeastern Nicaragua. Living Bird 10:185-242.
HUBER, W. 1932. Birds collected in northeastern Nicaragua in 1922. Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci-
ence of Philadelphia 84:205-249.
JLKS, H. 1991. The distribution of foraging wading birds in relation to the physical and
biological characteristics of freshwater wetlands in southwestern Florida. M.Sc. thesis,
University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida.
KUSHLAN, J. A., AND D. A. WHITE. 1977. Nesting wading bird populations in southern
Florida. Fla. Sci. 40:65-72.
LOPEZ ORNAT A., AND C. RAMO. 1992. Colonial waterbird populations in the Sian Ka'an
biosphere reserve (Quintana Roo, Mexico). Wilson Bulletin 104:501-515.
MONROE, B. L., JR. 1968. A distributional survey of the birds of Honduras. Ornithological
Monographs No. 7, American Ornithologists Union, Washington, D.C.
MORALES, G., AND J. PACHECO. 1986. Effects of diking of a Venezuelan savanna on avian
habitat, species diversity, energy flow, and mineral flow through wading birds. Colonial
Waterbirds 9:236-242.
NORTON-GRIFFITHS, n. 1975. Counting animals. Handbook no. 1. Nairobi, Kenya: African
Wildlife Leadership Foundation.
O(;)EN, J. C., C. E. KNO)ER, AN) A. SPRt'STJR. 1988. Colonial waterbird populations in the
Usamacinta delta, Mexico. Pp. 565-605, in Ecologia de los Rios Usamacinta y Grijalva.
Instituto Nacional de los Investigaciones sobre Recursos Bioticos, Tabasco, Mexico.
RICHMOND, C. W. 1893. Notes on a collection from eastern Nicaragua and the Rio Frio,
Costa Rica, with a description of a supposed new Trogon. Proc. Nat. Mus. 16:479-532.
S(;LATER, P. L. 1873. Additions to the list of birds of Nicaragua. Ibis 3:372-373.
--, AND O. SALkqN. 1867. List of birds collected from Blewfields River, Mosquito Coast.
Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond., 278-280.
SCOTT, D. h., AND M. CARBONEI.I.. 1986. A directory of neotropical wetlands. International
Waterfowl Research Bureau, Slimbridge, United Kingdom.
SP&XNS, A. L. 1990. Problems in assessing trends in breeding populations of Scarlet Ibises
and other ciconiiform birds. Pp. 1-6, in P. C. Frederick, L. G. Morales, A. L. Spaans,
and C. S. Luthin, eds. The Scarlet Ibis: Status, conservation and recent research. Inter-
national Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau Special Publication 4/11, Slimbridge,
United Kingdom.
STILES, F. G., AND A. F. SKUTCH. 1989. A guide to the birds of Costa Rica. Cornell Univer-
sit), Press, Ithaca, New York.
THOM.kS, B.T. 1985. Coexistence and behavior differences amont the three western hemi-
sphere storks. Pp. 921-931, in P. A. Buckley, M. S. Foster, E. S. Morton, R. S. Ridgley,
and F. G. Buckley, eds. Neotropical Ornithology, Ornithological Monograph No. 36,
American Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.
VILLRE^, J. 1996. Estado actual, ecologia trofica y uso de habitat delJabiru (Jabflu myc-
teria) en tres humedales de la cuenca baja del Tempisque, Costa Rica. MS thesis, Uni-
versidad Nacional, Herealia, Costa Rica.
WII,L, T. 1991. Birds of a severely hurricane-damaged Atlantic coast rain forest in Nicara-
gua. Biotropica 23:497-507.
Received 14 Mar. 1996; accepted 28 Aug. 1996.