863 University Drive
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan SYN 0J8 Canada
efore the settlement of the nearly treeless plains of
southern Saskatchewan (Houston and Bechard 1983),
cavity nesting birds such as the Mountain Bluebird (Sialia
currucoides) and Tree Swallow (Tachycineta bicolor) were
uncommon because of the lack of nest sites. They depend-
ed on decayed stumps and in the case of the bluebird,
crevices in clay cliffs. Settlement brought telephone poles
and fence posts with holes dug by Northern Flickers (Col-
apres auratus), mail boxes, twine boxes on binders, and
crevices in buildings. These made excellent nesting sites,
resulting in increasing numbers of Mountain Bluebirds
and Tree Swallows (Houston 1977).
Unfortunately, House Sparrows (Passer domesticus), follow-
ed in the 1940s by European Starlings ISturnus vulgaris),
also increased in number, and gradually usurped most of
the sites suitable for Mountain Bluebirds. The lack of nest
sites, and the resultant decrease in bluebird populations,
motivated Dr. Jack Lane of Brandon, Manitoba, and his
Junior Birders, to build and set out nest boxes, each with
an entrance hole 1.5 inches in diameter, too small to ad-
mit a starling. Observing Lane's success, Lorne Scott of
Figure 1. Map of Prairie Bluebird Trail from Denholm,
ß Glaslyn
Indian Head, Saskatchewan, began building boxes and
connected with Lane's trail in 1968. The Saskatoon Junior
Natural History Society began a trail that met with Scott's
in 1970 at Raymore, 120 miles southeast of Saskatoon
(Scott 1970, Houston 1971). By 1975 there were about
2500 miles of connecting trails with the extremities (at
Denholm, near North Battleford, Saskatchewan, and Win-
nipeg, Manitoba) about 600 miles apart (Figure 1).
For a few years we tried to monitor all boxes on the
western portion of the trail, as far east as Raymore, but
after 1973 we restricted regular visits to those 250 (on
average) boxes between Delisle and Hanley. This regularly
studied portion of the trail, from northwest to southeast,
is 76 miles long, 36 miles on the west side of the South
Saskatchewan river and 40 east of the river. All of these
boxes are within 40 miles of Saskatoon, and the most dis-
tant extremities are 48 miles apart (as the bluebird flies).
Our boxes are placed on fence posts. To minimize their
use by the House Sparrow and House Wren (Troglodytes
aedon), they are positioned away from farm yards and
preferably at a distance from trees or bushes. When the
boxes are placed along busy roads, there is less tempta-
tion for vandals to stop and investigate. The boxes are
Saskatchewan to Winnipeg, Manitoba.
ham
Dellsic
Russell
MONTANA
Rosel
MANITOBA
checked and repaired in early spring, then visited again
at least four times during the nesting season, to record
numbers of eggs, look for banded adults and to band both
adults and young. Although the objective -- "to bring back
the bluebirds" -- has been achieved, the greatest
beneficiary has been the Tree Swallow.
Late spring snowstorms or prolonged spells of cold rainy
weather can seriously decrease the production of young,
or delay the nesting period, or both. In 1982 a wet 6-inch
snowfall on 28 May followed by a period of cold weather
drastically reduced the food available. All but two clut-
ches from the first nesting of Mountain Bluebirds were
lost, and these were one and two weeks late. Some pairs
renested, making bluebird banding four weeks later than
usual, with fledging of only 132 young, compared to 335
one year earlier. Tree Swallows, which nest later than
bluebirds, delayed egg laying by eight or nine days, but
fledged a normal number of young (Houston 1982). In
1983, a heavy snowstorm on 9 May again delayed nesting
of both species by 10-14 days. Bluebirds were even more
seriously set back than the previous year and fledged only
100 young (Houston 1984). Although the Tree Swallows
fledged a usual number of young in 1983, the adult
females may have suffered unusual stress for only one
of them was recaptured in subsequent years.
One of us (MIH) tries to check each nest box every ten
days during the nesting season (it takes 4 full days each
time). Those adults caught on the nest are banded or, if
already banded, the bird number is recorded. Many
variables affect the number of banded adults recaptured
in a given year. In the first few years of the project when
crews of junior naturalists, who move more quickly, were
available to assist with banding, we caught more adults
before they could fly from the box. Other variables include
the weather -- adults sit more closely on cold damp days;
the stage of incubation -- once the eggs are laid and in-
cubation started, the female is more likely to stay on the
nest; and frequently, early morning is better than later in
the day. Once the young are a few days old, adults are
often out foraging, and can be caught only when they
return to the box with food. Only in 1970, 1973 and 1976
did we wait to catch, respectively, 2, 5 and 4 adult males
as they brought food to the young. Not one of these males
was recaptured later.
Table 1 gives the number of adult females and nestling
Tree Swallows banded each year and the number of each
age class recaught in a subsequent nesting season, from
1969 to 1985 inclusive. A much larger percentage of birds
banded as adults return (12.8%) than those banded as
nestlings (0.8%).
Birds found dead at or near a nest in subsequent years
have been included. Five swallows, four banded as locals,
included in the above calculations, were recaptured on
other bird house trails -- one in a nearby box of Doug
Finlay's and two in Mel Moline's boxes, 19 and 31 miles
further northwest. One banded in 1973 near Raymore
where we joined with Lorne Scott's trail, moved another
eight miles east to one of Lorne Scott's boxes. Another 11
swallows were encountered outside of our own boxes, in-
cluding one bird killed on the highway, and four that
moved into the city of Saskatoon, one of which was killed
by a cat.
Table 1. Annual Tree Swallow banding and encounter rates, 1969-1985.
Year Total Banded Adults Banded Adult Encounter Locals Banded Local Encounter
1969 193 17 4 176 2
1970 324 30 3 292 3
1971 662 76 6 586 5 +3
1972 664 80 13 584 7 +3
1973 495 99 8 391 6 +2
1974 446 67 18 379 2
1975 536 85 20 451 6
1976 574 67 13 503 4 +1
1977 663 52 13 611 4 +2
1978 684 65 12 619 3
1979 532 63 10 469 4
1980 586 58 6 528 6
1981 488 54 3 434 2
1982 525 59 6 466 3
1983 550 24 1 526 4
1984 486 53 8 433 3
1985 641 61 5 580 2
TOTAL* 9049 1010 149 8028 66 + 11
129 individuals 66 individuals
12.8% 0.8%
* Excluding 11 males (see text)
+Locals which returned in later years, after first return as adults
In Table 1, the "" numbers in the right column refer to
swallows banded as nestlings that returned more than
once as adults. These six individuals provided an addi-
tional 11 encounters beyond the first return. They are thus
of special interest as different from the other 59 returns
that were recaptured only once, not to mention the near-
ly 8000 other locals that were not encountered again. We
believe the six warrant individual mention:
123-33540. Banded June 1971.
Returned in 1973, 13.4 miles northwest of where banded;
in 1974, moved 1.7 miles south of its 1973 nest; in 1975,
returned to use its 1973 nest, 1.7 miles north.
123-33537. Banded June 1971.
Returned in 1973, 20.9 miles northwest of where banded;
in 1975, returned to use the 1973 nest.
124-30755. Banded in June 1972.
Returned in 1976, 5.9 miles northwest of where banded;
in 1978, 1979 and 1980, used the same nest box as in 1976.
820-18791. Banded in June 1973.
Returned in 1975, 9.5 miles southeast of where banded;
in 1978, moved 2.7 miles north and 0.7 miles west of the
1975 box; in 1979, moved 1.8 miles south and 0.4 miles
east of the 1978 box.
850-92882. Banded in June 1976.
Returned in 1980, 19.5 miles northwest of where banded;
in 1981, returned to use the 1980 nest.
880-31546. Banded in June 1977.
Returned in 1980, 2.4 miles northeast of where banded;
in 1981, moved another 0.3 miles east; in 1982, moved
a further 0.5 miles east.
For these six individuals, the average distance from the
nest where they were raised to their first recapture site
as nesting adults was 11.9 miles. However, for their 11
subsequent returns as adults, the average was only 0.8
miles.
Table 2 reports 149 recaptures of 129 female swallows
banded as adults. Although our recapturing of swallcws
hasn't been consistent enough to justify use of
sophisticated methods of annual mortality calculation, we
have used a simple method to calculate a mean annual
mortality of 53.9% from Table 2 {Hickey 1952). If one then
constructs a life table based on individuals known to be
alive, whether captured that year or not le.g., a first return
at 3 years allows one to include this individual in the
I-year and 2-year columns as well I, one derives a
somewhat higher mortality of 61.2% for the birds banded
as adult females {Table 3 I. Similarly, Table 4 gives data for
the first encounter of 66 swallows banded as nestlings,
with a mean annual mortality of 53.0%, while Table 5
gives this in life table format, with a similar 50.2% an-
nual mortality.
Table 2. Returns of all Tree Swallows banded as adult females.
YEARS FOLLOWING BANDING
NUMBER
YEAR BANDED 1 2 3 4 5 6
1969 17 2 1 1
1970 30 1 2
1971 76 4 I 1
1972 80 10 I 1 1
1973 99 4 1 3
1974 67 10 4 2 2
1975 85 12 3 3 1 1
1976 67 8 3 2
1977 52 11 2
1978 65 6 3 2 1
1979 63 7 3
1980 58 5 1
1981 54 3 --
1982 59 2 2 I I --
1983 24 I --
1984 53 4 4 --
1985 61 5 --
TOTALS 1010 92 33 16 4 3 1
CRUDE ANNUAL MORTALITY 64.1% 51.5% 75.0% 25.0%
MEAN ANNUAL MORALITY 53.9%
Table 3. Life table of all Tree Swallows banded as adult females.*
YEARS FOLLOWING BANDING
NUMBER
YEAR BANDED I 2 3 4 5 6
1969 17 3 3 1 1
1970 30 3 2
1971 76 5 2 1
1972 80 11 3 2 1
1973 99 6 4 3
1974 67 16 6 4 2 2
1975 85 16 5 2 1 1 1
1976 67 12 5 2
1977 52 11 2
1978 65 10 4 2 1
1979 63 8 3
1980 58 6 1
1981 54 3 --
1982 59 6 4 2 I --
1983 24 I I --
1984 53 7 4 --
1985 61 5 --
TOTALS 1010 116 44 19 7 3 1
CRUDE ANNUAL MORTALITY 62.1% 56.8% 63.2% 57.2% 66.7%
MEAN ANNUAL MORALITY 61.2%
*Known to be alive from later returns.
Table 4. First-time returns of Tree Swallows banded as locals.
YEARS FOLLOWING BANDING
NUMBER
YEAR BANDED I 2 3 4 5
1969 176 1
1970 292 2
1971 586 3
1972 584 4
1973 391
1974 379
1975 451 3
1976 503 1
1977 611 2
1978 619 1
1979 469 1
1980 528 3
1981 434 2
1982 466 2
1983 526 1
1984 433
1985 580 2
TOTALS 8028 28
CRUDE ANNUAL MORTALITY
MEAN ANNUAL MORALITY
2 1
4 1 1
1 1
1 2
2 1
I 1
1
2
1
2 I --
3 --
20 12 5
29% 60% 58%
53%
1
1
8o%
Table 5. Life table of all Tree Swallows banded as locals.*
YEARS FOLLOWING BANDING
NUMBER
YEAR BANDED I 2 3 4 5 6 ? 8
1969 176 2
1970 292 3
1971 586 5
1972 584 7
1973 391 6
1974 379 2
1975 451 6
1976 503 4
1977 611 4
1978 619 3
1979 469 4
1980 528 6
1981 434 2
1982 466 3
1983 526 4
1984 433 3
1985 580 2
TOTALS 8028 66
CRUDE ANNUAL MORTALITY
MEAN ANNUAL MORALITY
1
1
2 2
3 3
6 3
2 1
3 2
3 1
2 2
2 1
3 2
3 2
I 1
3 1
3 -
38 21
43% 45%
50.2 %
2
I 1
2 1
I 1
2 I
1
I I 1
1
10 5 2 I 1
53% 50% 60% 50%
*Known to be alive from later returns.
Table 6 summarizes the distance moved by each swallow
between encounters in different years. Although adult
females on 39 occasions (32 as first encounters and 7 in
subsequent years) returned to the same box where they
had nested previously, this was to our surprise more the
exception than the rule. Another 53 adult females (47 as
first encounters and 6 in subsequent years) nested bet-
ween 0.1 and 1.0 miles from the previous nest. In strik-
ing contrast, only one nestling returned as an adult to the
box in which it has been banded, while another returned
to a box across the road. Another 3 locals returned to nest
within one mile.
Within our study area, the maximum movement of an
adult female was 23.5 miles and that of a nestling to its
nesting box as an adult was 38.8 miles, close to the 48-mile
distance between our most separated boxes. The average
distance for adult females choosing a different box was
3.7 miles and for all adult females returning was 2.8 miles,
while for those banded as nestlings it was 9.5 miles. {In
1972, when we banded as far east as Raymore, a swallow
raised in a box west of Raymore flew the length of our
trail and far beyond to nest at Glaslyn, at a distance of
208 miles. If included, this increases the average distance
for all locals returning as adults to 12.5 miles.} The direc-
tion of dispersal was essentially random for both adult
females and locals.
Finally, we have captured two swallows banded by Lorne
Scott. One, banded as an adult female near Vibank in 1973
was recaptured in our box near Delisle in 1974, 168 miles
northwest of where she had nested earlier. (This type of
movement by adult females is probably more common
than the limited sampling of 250 boxes over a 76-mile trail
might suggest.) The second, banded as a nestling 7 miles
southwest of Fort Qu'Appelle in 1975, was recaptured in
1978 in our box near Pike Lake, 158 miles to the north-
west; this we suspect may be representative of the wide
dispersal distances of many nestlings.
Three swallows were found dead on the highway near
their nest box within six weeks of banding and have been
eliminated from any calculations. Four others, all banded
as locals, were recovered in August on their fall migra-
tion towards the southeast -- three in North Dakota and
one in Manitoba, having travelled remarkably similar
distances in an almost identical direction (Table 7). Lorne
ScoWs two recoveries to date also were in the same direc-
tion, one in North Dakota and one in Minnesota.
Table 6. Distance moved between nests -- by age at banding.
AT FIRST RETURN AT LATER RETURNS
DISTANCE LOCAL AD F LOCAL AD F
(miles) (number) (%) (number) (%) (number) (%) (number) (%)
0 2 3.0 32 24.8 5 45.6 7 35.0
0.1-1.0 3 4.6 47 36.4 2 18.1 6 30.0
1.1-5.0 18 27.3 27 20.9 4 36.3 5 25.0
5.1-10 18 27.3 13 10.1 2 10.0
11.1-20 16 24.2 6 4.6
20.1-30 5 7.6 4 3.1
31-40 3 4.6
40 + 1 1.5
TOTALS 66 100.1 129 99.9 11 100.0 20 100.0
Table 7. Tree Swallow recoveries during migration {all banded as locals).
Band number 830-11930 830-17273 880-41966 2010-88364
Banding date 6/29/75 6/21/76 7/08/77 6/25/85
Locat ion 515-1063 515-1064 515-1064 515-1063
North of Pike Lake Pike Lake North of
Dundurn, Sask. Sask. Sask. Dundurn, Sask.
Recovery date 8/30/75 8/12/76 8/??/77 8/26/85
How recovered Injured Injured Struck power Found dead
line
Location 481-0991 485-0983 492-0983 474-0991
7 mi N near 4 mi E NW of New
Minnewaukon, Wales, N.D. Somerset, Man. Rockford, N.D.
N.D.
Distance (km) 664 669 640 702
(miles) 413 416 398 436
Direction Degrees southeast 125 127 112 128
Extensive Tree Swallow banding in Saskatchewan has pro-
vided no information about the wintering quarters of our
birds nor about their migration route beyond North
Dakota. Nestlings disperse so widely that few are recap-
tured in subsequent years. Even adult females show much
less natal fidelity than might have been expected, and
even less than our limited sampling process would at first
glance suggest.
Acknowledgements
We wish to acknowledge the inspiration and guidance
provided by the late Dr. John Lane of Brandon and by
R. Lorne Scott of Indian Head, the enthusiasm of the
many juniors who built the houses, and the willingness
of the many helpers who have participated in the
surveillance of nest boxes. Scott provided detailed infor-
mation as to the location of three of his boxes.
Literature Cited
Hickey, J.J. 1952. Survival studies of banded birds. U.S.
Fish & Wildlife Service Special Scientific Report:
Wildlife No. 15. 177 pp.
Houston, C.S. 1977. The prairie bluebird trail. Nature
Canada 6 (2): 3-9.
----. and M.J. Bechard. 1983. Trees and the Red-tailed
Hawk in southern Saskatchewan. Blue Jay 41:99-109.
Houston, D.V. 1971. The prairie bluebird house trail. In-
land Bird Banding Association News 43:58-61.
Houston, M.I. 1982. Effects of a late May snowstorm on
Mountain Bluebird and Tree Swallow nesting. Blue Jay
40:206-207.
--. 1984. Mountain Bluebirds in Saskatchewan. Sialia
6:57-59.
Scott, R.L. 1970. Annual report of the Indian Head
bluebird trail. Blue Jay 28:176-177.