Division of Biological Sciences
University of Missouri-Columbia
Columbia, MO 65211
U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service
Institute of Tropical Forestry
Southern Forest Experiment Station
Call Box 25000, Rio Piedras,
Puerto Rico 00928-2500
nowledge of the lifespans of wild birds is of both
aesthetic interest and scientific importance. The ac-
cumulation of such knowledge can be accomplished
almost solely through the bird banding process. Clapp et
al. 11982,1983), Klimkiewicz et al. 11983), and Klimkiewicz
and Futcher (1987) have recently summarized longevity
records for North American birds through a survey of the
Bird Banding Laboratory's records.
Little information exists about longevity of Neotropical
birds, in part because of the limited amount of bird ban-
ding that has been done in that region. Here we present
estimates of the longevity of Puerto Rican birds gathered
during a 15-year study at a single site on that island.
Although the number of birds banded cannot compare to
the totals for all North American bandings Isee above
references I, the longevities recorded are often quite com-
parable and provide an interesting first estimate of
lifespans for tropical island birds. Additionally, winter site
fidelity in some migratory birds provides longevity records
comparable to those recorded on the breeding grounds.
Study Site and Methods
Our banding studies have been done in the Guanica Forest
of southwestern Puerto Rico, a 4000 ha reserve that is
coverd with the dry scrub forest typical of such climates
in the West Indies. Although this area receives nearly 100
cm of rain yearly, little rain falls from December to April.
During this period, drying winds, shallow soils, and bright
sunlight make for extremely arid conditions which results
in a forest that is partially evergreen and includes many
arborescent cacti. The short nature of the vegetation
(usually less than 20 feet tall) makes mist netting a highly
effective technique for sampling the bird population.
We have been using a line of mist nets as a population
monitoring tool Isee Faaborg et al. 1984), using the tech-
nique outlined in Terborgh and Faaborg 119731. All ban-
dings reported here were from a single straight line of 16
mist nets 136 mm mesh, 12 m long, Association of Field
Ornithologists type ATX) placed as close to end-to-end as
possible and run from dawn to dusk for three consecutive
days. The number of new individuals captured declines
sharply during this period, such that only about 20% of
the three-day total is captured on the third day. Samples
have been collected during January or early February of
every year from 1973 through 1988 except 1977 and 1979,
plus samples were taken in June of 1973 and October of
1986.
All birds captured were banded, weighed, measured, and
released. Recaptures (birds banded in previous years)
allow us to estimate avian longevity in this location. We
have followed the standard procedure (see Clapp et al.
1982) of listing longevity records as years-months (0-00).
The longest recapture period is the length of time between
banding and last recapture of a bird. Estimated maximum
longevity is the above period plus the time from initial
banding to the previous June 1, assuming that all birds
were born on that date. Average recapture time is the
average time between first and last captures for all in-
dividuals of a species caught in two different sampling
periods.
Results and Discussion
We have captured 39 species of birds in this netline over
the 15-year period. Of these, 18 have never been recap-
tured in subsequent sampling periods (Table 1). Often, this
is due to very small sample sizes; in other cases, it sug-
gests mobile bird populations, both among winter
residents (such as the Cape May and Prairie Warblers) and
residents (such as the Black-faced Grassquit I. Recapture
information is not available for hummingbirds, as we clip
tails to mark them.
There is great variation in the longevity characteristics of
birds that have been captured in at least two samples
ITable 2 I. Some species Isuch as the Common Ground
Dove I have large sample sizes but show low recapture
rates and short longevity estimates. In other cases, near-
ly 30% of banded individuals have been recaptured, often
several times, and even average longevity is high. In a few
cases, the presence of apparently sedentary individuals
has given us a long recapture time despite either small
total samples or low recapture rates.
Several records are worthy of note. Perhaps the most im-
pressive recapture is that of a Puerto Rican Tody which
was banded in February, 1974, and recaptured 4 other
times, the last in January of 1988. This period of 13 years,
11 months between banding and last capture and an
estimated 14 years, 6 month of age is amazing for a 5.5
g bird living in such a harsh environment! Although the
estimated ages of 11 years, 7 months for the Puerto Rican
Flycatcher and Pearly-eyed Thrasher are impressive, these
birds are appreciably larger (22 and 100 g, respectivelyI
and seemingly more durable than the body. The age
estimate of the flycatcher is exceeded in North America
only by the Great Crested Flycatcher IMyiarchus crinitus;
13 years, 11 months [Clapp et al. 198311 among congeners.
The longevity of the Pearly-eyed Thrasher exceeds all of
these shown for members of the North American
Mimidae in Klimkiewicz et al. 11983 I.
The maximum longevity estimate for the Puerto Rican
Vireo exceeds those listed for nearly all North American
vireos IKlimkiewicz et al., 1983 I. Such is also the case for
the resident Adelaide's Warbler when compared to North
American warblers of the genus Dendroica. Although we
have found that the Northern Parula rarely is recaptured,
one of our recaptures gives an estimated maximum
longevity of 7 years, 7 months, which exceeds that listed
in Klimkiewicz et al. (1983) by nearly 3 years. Although
only one individual Prothonothary Warbler was ever
recaptured, it appeared in the same net over a 4-year span.
This longevity estimate of 4 years, 7 month is close to
the 4 years, 11 months listed by Klimkiewicz et al. (1983 I.
Although one can point out examples like those above it
is difficult to make generalizations about the differences
between Puerto Rican and North American birds through
such comparisons. Yet, given that we are comparing a few
dozen to a few hundred birds banded at a single location
with often thousands of birds banded throughout North
America, one cannot help but get the impression that
these resident birds of Puerto Rico are rather long lived,
despite the seeming harshness of the seasonally dry forests
in which they live.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank our wives and many colleagues,
students, and friends who have helped with the netting
over the years. The Department of Natural Resources of
the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico has always been very
helpful in granting us permission to do this work. In re-
cent years, Miguel Canals, biologist for the Puerto Rican
Department of Natural Resources, has provided assistance
on a daily basis. Financial support for this work has come
from the Frank M. Chapman Fund of the American
Museum of Natural History, the Research Council of the
Graduate School, University of Missouri-Columbia, the
U.S. Agency for International Development, and the U.S.
Forest Service, Institute of Tropical Forestry.
We also wish to thank James L. Ingold for valuable com-
ments on the manuascript.
Literature Cited
Clapp, R.B., M.K. Klimkiewicz, and J.H. Kennard. 1982.
Longevity records of North American birds: Gaviidae
through Alcidae. J. Field Ornithol. 53: 81-124.
Clapp, R.B., M.K. Klimkiewicz, and A.G. Futcher. 1983.
Longevity records of North American birds: Colum-
bidae through Paridae. J. Field Ornithol. 543:123-137.
Faaborg, J., w.J. Arendt, and M.S. Kaiser. 1984. Rainfall
correlates of bird population fluctuations in a Puerto
Rican dry forest: A nine year study. Wilson Bull.
96:575-593.
Klimkiewicz, M.K., R.B. Clapp, and A.G. Futcher. 1983.
Longevity records of North American birds: Remizidae
through Parulinae. J. Field Ornithol. 54:287-294.
Klimkiewicz, M.K. and A.G. Futcher. 1987. Longevity
records of North American birds: Coerebinae through
Estrildidae. J. Field Ornithol. 58:318-333.
Terborgh, J., and J. Faaborg. 1973. Turnover and ecological
release in the avifauna of Mona Island, Puerto Rico.
Auk 90:759-779.
Table
1. Species and numbers of birds banded in the
Guanica Forest which have never been recap-
tured in subsequent samples.
SPECIES NO, BANDED
American Kestrel (Falco sparverius) 1
Zenaida Dove (Zenaida aurita) 3
Key West Quail-dove (Geotrygon chrysia) 12
Puerto Rican Screech-owl (Otus nudipes) 1
Puerto Rican Nightjar (Caprimulgus noctitherus) 1
Antillean Mango (Anthracothorax dominicus) 24
Puerto Rican Emerald (Chlorostilbon maugaeus) 1
Gray Kingbird (Tyrannus dominicensis) 1
Gray-cheeked Thrush* (Catharus minimus) 1
Cape May Warbler* (Dendroica tigrina) 23
Prairie Warbler* (Dendroica discolor) 18
Northern Water-thrush* (Seiurus noveboracensis)* 1
Hooded Warbler* (Wilsonia citrina) 6
Wilson's Warbler* (Wilsonia pusilia) 1
Blue-hooded Euphonia (Euphonia musica) 6
Indigo Bunting* ,asserina cyanea) 1
Black-faced Gras61uit (Tiaris bicolor) 34
Shiny Cowbird (Molothrus bonariensis) I
*denotes winter resident
Table 2. Banding and longevity information for bird species banded and recaptured in the Guanica Forest, Puerto
Rico. See text for explanations of terms.
NO. BIRDS NO. OF MEAN RECAP- LONGEST ESTIMATED
SPECIES NO. BANDED RECAPTURED RECAPTURES TURE TIME RECAPTURE LONGEVITY
Common Ground Dove
(Columbina passerina) 50
Mangrove Cuckoo (Coccyzus minor) 9
Puerto Rican Lizard-cuckoo
(Saurothera vieilloti) 8
Puerto Rican Tody (Todus mexicanus) 40
Puerto Rican Woodpecker
(Melanerpes portoricensis) 11
Caribbean Elaenia (Elaenia martinica) 60
Puerto Rican Flycatcher
(Myiarchus antillarum) 56
Red-legged Thrush (Turdus plumbeus) 50
Pearly-eyed Thrasher
(Margarops fuscatus) 101
Puerto Rican Vireo (Vireo latimeri) 19
Northern Parula* (Parula americana) 36
Adelaide's Warbler
(Dendroica adelaidae) 68
Black-and-white Warbler*
(Mniotilta varia) 47
American Redstart*
(Setophaga ruticilla) 62
Prothonotary Warbler*
(Protonotaria citrea) 3
Ovenbird* (Seiurus aurocapillus) 24
Bananaquit (Coereba flaveola) 291
Stripe-headed Tanager
(Spindalls zena) 24
Puerto Rican Bullfinch
(Loxigilla portoricensis) 228
Black-cowled Oriole
(Icterus dominicensis) 2
Troupial (Icterus icterus) 15
3 3 1-08 2-00 2-07
1 1 2-00 2-00 2-07
2 3 1-08 3-00 3-07
7 15 3-11 13-11 14-06
2 2 2-06 4-00 4-07
6 10 2-00 5-00 5-07
16 29 4-00 11-00 11-07
14 21 3-06 7-00 7-07
18 28 3-08 11-00 11-07
7 14 2-09 8-09 9-04
2 2 4-00 7-00 7-07
10 13 2-05 6-11 7-06
13 19 1-11 4-00 4-07
11 13 1-11 6-11 7-06
1 2 4-00 4-00 4-07
4 4 1-09 2-00 2-07
38 55 2-00 6-00 6-07
4 4 2-01 6-00 6-07
46 63 2-03 7-00 7-07
1 2 1-11 1-11 2-06
2 2 2-11 3-11 4-06
*denotes winter resident
IBBA CALL FOR PAPERS
The 1989 meeting of the Inland Bird Banding Association will be held on
September 8-10, 1989 at the University of Minnesota Raptor Rehabilitation
Center on the St. Paul campus. All members and banders are invited and
encouraged to submit abstracts for papers or posters covering any aspect
of banding, for inclusion in the scientific session to be held on Saturday,
September 9th. For information and guidelines, please contact Betsy Jones,
Dept. of Veterinary Biology, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of
Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108, home phone: 612-490-1975, work phone:
612-624-5322. Abstracts are due no later than June 1, 1989.