1. TRIBE ANSERINI. SWANS AND GEESE
The birds commonly known as swans and geese agree so closely
in structure, in pattern of downy plumage, in general behavior and
courtship, and in living and nesting habits, that they cannot be
separated as two distinct tribes. Swans differ from geese only in
their larger size, shorter legs, longer necks, and greater number of
vertebrae; none of these characters is taxonomically important, not
even the number of vertebrae, since this varies considerably from
species to species.
The Anserini differ sharply from most of the other waterfowl.
The two sexes are always similar in plumage, and nearly so in voice,
the voice of the female being merely a little higher pitched. They
never have any metallic colors, and the downy young never have a
strongly marked pattern. The nuptial display and mating antics
are all simple and vary little among the species; the only courtship
consists of stretching the neck and of "dipping." They apparently
pair for life, and both male and female always participate in the
care of the young. Usually it is the female which incubates, while
the male guards the nest. In the exceptional case of the Black Swan
("Chenopis" atratus), the male shares to some extent the duty of in-
cubation. Sexual maturity is not attained until the second or third
year. Swans and geese have only one annual molt and consequently
have no eclipse plumage. They nest on the ground; a few species
nest occasionally on ledges or in old nests. Their food is mostly
vegetable, obtained by grazing and dipping. Their syrinx is sym-
metrical and has no bulla.
We consider all swans as congeneric, the fact that some have
black in the plumage being of little importance. The most primitive
swans are arranged in two pairs of forms: bewicki (Old World) and
columbianus (New World); cygnus (Old World) and buccinator (New
World). As Hartert has already suggested, these are best considered
two Holarctic species (C. columbianus and C. cygnus). The four
forms are alike in behavior patterns. Each of the three other species
of the genus stands rather alone, although the Mute Swan (C. olor)
and the Australian Black Swan (C. atratus) show certain similarities.
The threat behavior of lifting the wings, which is so typical of the
Mute Swan and occurs in a less pronounced way in the Black Swan,
is absent in the Black-necked Swan (C. melanocoryphus) as well as
in the four primitive forms.
Pair formation, which occurs in the fall in all temperate-zone
swans, takes place without elaborate displays. According to Heinroth
(1911), birds that are in the process of pairing swim in close proximity,
J. Delacour THE FAMILY ANATIDAE 9
Ernst Mayr
press the plumage close to the body, and hold the neck in a peculiar
position, the head appearing thickened. Swans, geese, and whistling
ducks (tree ducks) have essentially the same precopulatory display:
both birds of a pair repeatedly dip the whole head and neck until
finally the female flattens herself out on the water and sinks deeper
with the neck half extended. But there are a number of variations; for
example, in swans male and female frequently face each other and
half rise out of the water, breast to breast. All swans, except the
Mute Swan, have been observed diving, although rarely. They
seem to be the only Anatidae which have the habit of taking their
downy young on the back when the young are tired or cold. This is
the usual practice with Mute and Black-necked Swans. It is ex-
ceptional in the other species.
Amongst the geese, there is no ground for retaining the genera
Chen, Cygnopsis, Eulabeia, and -Philacte, all the species referred to
them being members of the genus Anser. All have more or less strong
serrations on the sides of the bill. Branta is characterized by a more
elaborate plumage pattern, a longer and thinner neck, and smaller
and smoother bill (Figure 2). The Hawaiian Goose ("Nesochen")
certainly belongs in this genus (Figure 3). Hybrids from crosses
between species of Anser are usually fertile, and so are those between
species of Branta, but hybrids from crosses between the two genera
are sterile.
The Russian workers (for references and summary see Ernst
Hartert and F. Steinbacher, 1936, "Die V6gel der palarktischen
Fauna", Erg. Bd., Heft 5:433-434) have shown that brachyrhynchus
and neglectus.are races of fabalis. The extensive breeding ranges of
Anser erythropus (inland) and A. albifrons (coastal) run parallel along
the north of Europe and Asia. No overlap of the ranges of the two
species is known, and it has therefore been suggested (Witherby et al.,
1939) that the two forms be considered subspecies of erythropus.
Further work may show that this view is correct.
The most characteristic feature of the geese is their closely knit
family life. The family migrates as a unit, and the young apparently
remain with their parents until the beginning of the new breeding
season.
The "triumph ceremony," which is characteristic of the geese,
has been described as follows: "After driving off intruder all geese
behave similarly; gander hurries back to mate with special 'triumph-
note' . . . in which she joins, uttered with neck stretched out and
head close to ground. Even downy young take part, assuming same
attitudes as parents" (Witherby et al., 1939:182, after tteinroth).
The same "triumph ceremony" is an important part of the pair-
formation display. The courting gander drives away weaker birds
and then returns to the chosen goose with the "triumph note." At
first, she may not pay much attention to his behavior, but if she
March 1945
10 THE WILSON BULLETIN vol. 57. o. 1
answers his call and joins in the display, the pair formation may be
considered completed. The gander swims in a peculiarly proud,
erect position in the water during this courtship period and may
indulge in "dipping displays" even before pair formation. The pre-
copulatory display is the same as in the swans.
Geese are highly social, as are most grazing animals. Mani-
festations of social rank seem to be absent in the wild, but develop
in confinement when the source of food is localized. Geese mature
in the second year, and pair formation takes place in the second
winter. The habits of the various species of Branta seem to be
essentially the same as those of Anser, except that the smaller species
feed to a greater extent on water plants.
The very peculiar Coscoroba coscoroba, from South America,
occupies a special place. It reminds one of a swan by its white color
and some of its habits. Particularly, it raises its wings in anger
as the Mute and the Black Swan do. At the same time, its voice
(a not very loud, trumpeting cos-c6roba) and its display are entirely
peculiar. In some other features (in shape of head, for example) it
resembles the whistling ducks, it has their long legs and large feet,
their comparatively rounded wings (Figures 4 and 5). The downy
young, extremely rare in collections, is, like a cygnet, whitish-gray,
but it shows in darker gray, distinctly if weakly, the very special
markings of the downy whistling duck, notably the light band across
the nape. As in swans, the syrinx is without a bulla, even in the male.
Coscoroba, in fact, seems to be an intermediate, linking the swan-
goose group to the whistling ducks, and on that account is of very
great interest. On the basis of the scanty information available, the
genus Coscoroba could be placed in either group. A thorough study
of its anatomical features, of its pair formation, and of the partici-
pation of the male in incubation and raising of the young is needed
before the species can be classified with confidence.
2. TRIBE DENDROCYGNINI. WHISTLING DUCKS (TREE DUCKS")
Whistling ducks are among the least known of all the ducks.
There is not a single good life history of any of the species, nor is
there an anatomical comparison of the tribe with other Anserinae.
The tribe is composed of a single genus (Dendrocygna) with eight
species. Whistling ducks have no close relatives except Coscoroba.
Their high-pitched, squeaking voice and a number of their habits
are peculiar to the tribe.
They have a number of features in common with the other
Anserinae. Both sexes take care of the young. The male shares
(?always) in the duties of incubation, as in the Black Swan; in fact,
in vlduata and bicolor the male seems to have the greater share. The
two sexes are alike in coloration and similar in voice; they seem to
J. Delacour THE FAMILY ANATIDAE 11
Ernst Mayr
pair for life. There is no metallic color in the plumage. Whistling
ducks resemble geese in postures (Figure 6) and display. Their food
consists mostly of vegetable material and is obtained by grazing,
dipping, or diving. They are expert divers and gather much of their
food under water. They nest usually on the ground, in reeds or tall
grass, where they build an elaborate nest, well concealed by bent-over
stalks; they nest occasionally in holes in trees or in abandoned
nests of other birds. Their eggs are white and rather round. The
pre- and post-copulatory displays are the same as those of swans
and geese, different from those of the Anatinae: male and female
face each other, lift the breast out of the water, and slightly raise
their wings.
Their syrinx has symmetrical bullae, slightly larger in the male
than in the female. The plumage patterns of adults and downy
young are peculiar, different from those of all other Anatidae (ex-
cepting only Coscoroba as noted above). The fully adult plumage
is attained the first year. The species of whistling ducks show very
little geographical variation.
In spite of their common name these ducks seldom perch in trees.
Some species never do, while others perch only occasionally--not
nearly so regularly as the members of the tribe Cairinini. Hence
"whistling ducks" is a much more appropriate name for this group
than "tree ducks."
The eight species of Dendrocygna can be divided into three groups:
a primitive group (perhaps only one superspecies) consisting of
arborea (West Indies) and guttata (East Indies); secondly the some-
what isolated species autumnalis (America); and finally a group of
five closely related species, javanica (southeast Asia, Malaysia), the
superspecies bicolor (America, Africa, India) and arcuata (Malaysia,
Papua, Australia), eytoni (Australia), and the specialized viduata
(America, Africa, Madagascar).