uch has been written concerning the pathways followed by birds that
pass back and forth in seasonal migration but, in North America,
these items pertain largely to the eastern and mid-western sections. Many of
the routes followed are hypothetical, being drawn with the ruler laid down on
the map and connecting the breeding area with wintering area or point of
release with point of recapture, too little being known as to the specific route
followed. Furthermore, even those excellent accounts that report the bird in
actual transit deal with migrants flying at low elevations and where topog-
raphy of land surface enters as a determining factor and the element of guid-
ance receives the major emphasis.
In the western United States some local flylines seemingly are determined
by contrasting elevation and the correlated conserving of energy on the
part of the bird. Relatively low basins are isolated by high and abrupt moun-
tain masses through which water gaps and faulting lines form the main path-
ways of communication. These mountain passes may constitute pathways of
seasonal migration or of slower diffusion through a succession of years. The
factors of guidance or of upwelling air currents may participate but they
appear to be of minor significance.
Many years of field work on my part in California and Arizona have re-
suited in some rather distinct impressions supported by definite data. These
impressions, used in oral presentation before classes in ornithology, I have
been urged to present in some more permanent medium.
THE ROLE OF FAULT LINES
One striking character in the physiography of California is the multitude
of its fault lines. The San Andreas, Garlock, Elsinore, and Sierra Madre
faults--to mention but a few, have I am confident had an influence upon bird
movement (Fig. 1). My many camps along one or another of these lines
have given me the feeling that they constitute fly-lines for birds that are even
more definite than some of the sky-ways of human aviators and sometimes for
comparable reasons.
The San 4ndreas Fault.This great fault begins with the extended trough
of the Gulf of California, in Mexico. Here in late March of 1938, I watched
the California Gulls (Larus californicus) organizing their bands to set forth
on the northwestward drift to the breeding grounds in the basin country of
California and Nevada.
Farther along this fault the Coachella Valley, leading into San Gorgonio
Pass, offers a pathway ranging from below sea level at Indio to approximately
164
Loye AVIAN FLYWAYS 165
Miller
2,000 feet at Banning, whereas the mountains on either side of the pass rise
to 10,800 and 11,400 feet. Many observations have been made along this
segment of the fault. Birds actually watched in transit are recorded as
follows--
March 15, 1913.--A mixed flock of Vaux Swifts (Chaetura vauxi), Violet-green
(Tachycineta), Cliff (Petrochelidon), Tree (lridoprocne) and Barn (Hitundo) swallows
moving slowly to the northwest.
April 18, 1916.--A flock of the same species moving similarly. In addition t.here was
one Belted Kingfisher (Megaceryle alcyon) by himself.
k:d q \ ; ; .v , Gu,,o,1/2o,,orn,o,oCen,ro, vo,ey
_ k ' ;] Y Erosion Poss Arroyo Seco
' --- '" Erosion Poss Keorsorge Poss
'k ':::{-;;;Ck ,/:' Greet Centrol Volley (Orogenic)
ß -' ,. ;.:._ . , '..
.... ..:,:.'"'"'.:,:, / ( ' '..
....<:A2;, 3/4 ,... -.,
?; ...... .. .......
. 2 / ' k;:. : ......... . ........
,s,,o ",. ::%
Fzc. 1. Outline map locating routes in California that are mentioned in the text. Den-
sity of stippling suggests concentration of migrants through narrow parts of passes.
Prepared by Gene Christman.
June 1957
166 THE WILSON BULLETIN vol. 69, No. a
April 2, 1920.--Barn, Violet-green and Tree swallows in flocks. Not in flocks were
Scott's Oriole (Icters parisorum), Tohnie Warbler (Oporornis tolmiei), Yellow-throat
(Geothlypis trichas) and Black-crowned Night Heron (Nycticorax).
March 26, 1921.--Violet-green Swallows in flock.
March 30, 1921.--A dozen Phainopepla nitens in a fairly close flock moving out through
the pass.
April 8, 1922.--An Osprey (Pandion haliaetus) beating out the pass against the wind
just above the desert shrubs. A large flock of Swainson's Hawks (Buteo swainsoni) tar-
ried to feed on sphynx moth larvae at a point below sea level. On one spring trip a flock
of White-fronted Geese (Anser albi[rons) worked northward through the pass near White-
water Ranch. They were flying less than 15 feet above the creosote bushes and tacking
back and forth against a strong headwind.
April 9, 1922.--Large numbers of Lewis Woodpeckers (Asyndesmus lewis) at the north-
western end of the pass below Beaumont.
Further items are merely repetitious and need not be included.
From San Gorgonio Pass the fault leads northwest through Cajon Pass
and Swarthout Canyon to Antelope Valley, which is occupied by desert veg-
etation of Joshua tree, creosote bush, various cacti and sagebrush. Here
during the spring migrations, I have observed steadily moving flocks of sand-
pipers and White Pelicans (Pelecanus erythrorhynchos) close above the
Joshua tree forest and a single Bonaparte Gull (Larus philadelphia) in high
plumage that seemed to be catching a meal of grasshoppers en route.
Near old Fort Tejon the San Andreas Fault breaks across the southern end
of the great Interior Valley of California, the Sacramento-San Joaquin basin
that runs for the major part of the length of the state at an elevation of less
than 2,000 feet and migrant birds have no further need of the great fault
as a flyway to the northward.
The local subsidary fault of Mill Creek Canyon lies parallel with San
Gorgonio Pass but at a higher elevation. It is separated by a relatively low
notch from the Whitewater River on the desert side and debauches into the
San Bernardino Valley to the westward where it connects with Cajon Pass
of the major San Andreas Fault. On August 24, 1913, just before sunset, I
saw a flock of Phainopeplas flying through this canyon in close formation
like a flock of blackbirds. They are not found in this canyon ordinarily but
these individuals were seemingly moving from the San Bernardino area to
their wintering grounds in the Colorado Desert, perhaps as far south as
Sonora. Abundant mistletoe berries furnish a winter food supply for a large
population of this species in the Colorado Desert basin.
The Elsinore Fault.--In the early history of California as a state the Butter-
field Stage Company played an important part in connecting coastal southern
California with the eastern United States. Part of the stage route through
the mountain and desert barrier to the eastward followed the Elsinore Fault
that opens into the valley of the Santa Ana River near the present city of
Corona. Along this fault near the site of the former stage station of Temescal
Loye AVIAN FLYWAYS 167
Miller
I found on April 9 of 1907, numbers of Lewis Woodpeckers in northward
movement and in August of 1908 large flocks of White Pelicans.
The ephemeral Lake Elsinore and Lee Lake occupy this depression. In
certain rainfall cycles, the White Pelicans are abundant on Lake Elsinore.
The Santa Ana Mountains rise very abruptly to an elevation of 5,600 feet
along the west side of the fault. The pelicans seemingly preferred not to
scale this high wall.
The Garlock Fault.--This transverse fault extends for many miles across
the southern end of the Sierran block to cut through the mountains east of
Bakersfield via Tehachapi Pass and connect the Mojave Desert with the
great Central Valley. Through this pass two great railway systems send all
their eastbound traffic from the San Joaquin Valley. The Garlock joins the
San Andreas Fault in the vicinity of old Fort Tejon. Along its course there
may have diffused the several species of desert plants and animals that are
found in the southern end of the San Joaquin Valley.
Only once have I been fortunate enough to observe it as a "fly-line" in
active use. On one of my spring trips to Berkeley, I stood on the observation
platform of a Southern Pacific train near Mojave Station and watched a
flock of gray geese flying low over the desert scrub, overtake our laboring
train and pass on through the notch cut through the Tehachapi Mountains
by the Garlock Fauk.
THE ROLE OF EROSION PASSES
A fascinating aspect of biologic study in southern Arizona is the mixture
of northern and southern faunas that one encounters there. This blending
takes place, to be sure, across a man-made political boundary not visible to
the wild creature. Nevertheless there are certain pathways that are recog-
nizable. Two of these have been especially evident in my field studies. One
of them is the valley of the Santa Cruz River. From the region of Nogales
it runs northward to join the Gila River beyond Tucson and thence into the
great Colorado basin. The Beardless Flycatcher (Camptostoma imberbe),
Ferruginous Pigmy Owl (Glaucidium brasilianum), and Boat-tailed Grackle
(Cassidix mexicanus), to mention but a few, come northward along this path
into Arizona.
In early April of 1894, I saw a flock of about a dozen Black-headed Gros-
beaks (Pheucticus melanocephalus) migrating along this fly line. They were
all males, they were in a compact flock and moved steadily northward over
the desert vegetation just out of old Tucson.
About 15 miles west of Nogales the Pajarito Mountains are cut through
by the narrow gorge of Sycamore Canyon that is occupied by a stream flow-
ing south into the Magdalena drainage of Sonora. By way of this canyon we
June 1957
168 THE WILSON BULLETIN Vol. 69. No. 2
have received from Mexico a number of plant species, a small minnow, a
frog, and a tree snake. On June 30, 1945, all at once the canyon was en~
livened with the calls of many Yellow-billed Cuckoos. They were not there
during the two previous days and by July 2 they were heard no more. On
June 30, also, two strange raptors were observed passing through the gorge
close to our camp. My camp mate, A. J. van Rossera, and I saw them but
neither could name them. We were quite in agreement, however, that they
were strangers to the North American fauna. They disappeared slowly down
'the gorge and have remained an enigma ever since.
The San Gabriel Mountains of California make up the east-west barrier
that separates the coastal plain of the Los Angeles area from the Mojave
Basin to the northward. The deepest erosion notch through this range is cut
by the Arroyo Seco that descends into the busy metropolitan area near where
the little Mexican pueblo of Nuestra Senora La Reina de Los Angeles was
first established in the early days of Spanish colonization.
For 25 years my home was on the west bank of this waterway that I soon
learned was likewise a flyway. A high gear automobile road now takes ad-
vantage of this gateway through the wall but the birds must have used it for
a geologic period. Time and again we have stood on our overlook balcony
and watched the flocks of White Pelicans ploughing the air up the Arroyo
Seco only a few hundred feet above the housetops. About the last of March
I would begin to expect them and have even made bold at times to predict
(with success) that, within the week, some of us would see the White Peli-
cans passing northward up the canyon headed for the Great Basin. One
spring I happened to be on the slopes of Mt. Wilson when a flock came in.
They had not gained quite enough altitude to take them safely through the
notch, so they had to circle in an up current. I actually looked down upon
the backs of these great birds, some of them measuring upwards of eight
feet in wing spread. They looked most incongruous against the pine trees of
the mountain sides.
Much of the eastern border of California is separated from the Great Basin
area by the high, abrupt wall of the Sierra Nevada. In this area akitude must
certainly influence the course of migration, since much of the range lies at
12,000 feet or more, and gateways at lower levels offer a distinct advantage
to heavy bodied birds during extended flights.
One such gateway lies at the head of the American River near which I
camped for two summers. Here again the White Pelicans were observed on
June 15, 1919, passing between the interior valley of California and their
breeding grounds at Pyramid Lake in the Great Basin country. They flew
so low over the pine tops that the rush of their wings was like escaping steam.
Another summer we were camped at Bull Frog Lake on the west side of
Kearsarge Pass in the southern part of the Sierra. On August 23, 1928, I
Loye AVIAN FLYWAYS 169
Miller
stumbled up to the pass in the half light of dawn to watch the sun come up
out of the desert to the eastward. I was soon diverted, however, to bird-
watching and spent nearly four hours beside the survey marker that registered
11,823 feet. Peaks rose abruptly another thousand or more feet on either
side, the divide was almost knife-edge sharp and devoid of vegetation, yet
birds were moving through. Chipping Sparrows (Spizella passerina), Audu-
bon's Warblers (Dendroica audubonii) and a small greenish warbler passed
through from the west. One Red-tailed Hawk (Buteo ]amaicensis) went
through but the most impressive was a flock of White-fronted Geese (Anser
albi]rons). Just as the sun came up a dozen of these geese came wedging
their way in from the northeast headed for their wintering grounds among
the grain fields of the great Central Valley. They cleared the pass by what
seemed only a few inches--almost scraping their checkered breasts on the
sharp rocks but a few dozen yards from me. They had probably been flying
all night and they were conserving every ounce of fuel. Their steady wing
beats carried them through the notch and out over the lower parts of the
canyon where the sun had not yet risen. I saw them disappear into the blue
shadow whence they could plane down to a resting ground in the marshy
country about Buena Vista or Tulare lakes. I wondered how many genera-
tions of their ancestors had followed that same trail through the notch of
Kearsarge Pass.
True it is that many observations have been made that record birds mi-
grating at fairly high altitudes and quite independent of surface topography.
Here they may gain ultimately by advantageous air currents or meteorologic
"fronts." On the other hand, I am inclined to believe that, all other factors
being equal, the bird will fly at a moderate altitude if no barrier confronts
him, and that mountain passes here in the West have determined some very
definite fly lines.
S u M MARY
Actual observations of moving birds through mountain passes in California
and Arizona are put on record. These passes are discussed under two heads--
fault lines and erosion gaps. It is postulated that altitude is an important
factor in the bird's metabolic economy during migration. Hence it may deter-
mine the migration route.
MUSEUM OF VERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY, BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA, JULY 27, 1956